Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Lee questions MOIA on challenges of being a mayoral office versus agency

New York City Council · May 28, 2026 · starts 4:39:43 · 1 min 54 sec

Lee asks about limitations of MOIA's structure as a coordinating office rather than a standalone agency. Ali acknowledges limitations but highlights strengths of proximity to executive decision-making at City Hall, and calls for broader stakeholder conversation about potential transition.

Linda Lee

Okay, so I'll go through my questions quickly because I know we have others that need to ask questions.

Linda Lee

So since MOIA is a mayoral office technically and not a full-fledged city agency, what specific challenges and limitations does this structure present in terms of funding, operational capacity, and policy implementation?

Linda Lee

Because I know you have to go across a lot of different city agencies.

Member of the Public - Faiza Ali

Yeah, this is a great question.

Member of the Public - Faiza Ali

I think it's actually a really important conversation that should be had.

Member of the Public - Faiza Ali

And it does, you know, I think that it deserves.

Member of the Public - Faiza Ali

More nuanced and sort of a binary answer of like should MOIA be an agency or not.

Member of the Public - Faiza Ali

You know right now MOIA's structure as an office it does create certain limitations because we are like you said fundamentally a coordinating office rather than a standalone operational

Member of the Public - Faiza Ali

agency and much of our work does require sustained partnership across city government.

Member of the Public - Faiza Ali

But at the same time, I think that there are some real strengths to the current structure that we should take into consideration.

Member of the Public - Faiza Ali

Being housed within City Hall, for example, gives MOIA

Member of the Public - Faiza Ali

the direct proximity to executive decision-making on issues related to immigrants and immigrant inclusion,

Member of the Public - Faiza Ali

it really allows us to also elevate our concerns as a citywide priority rather than being siloed into a standalone agency.

Member of the Public - Faiza Ali

But I say all this to say that, you know, I think it's really important for me, and I'm glad you raised the issue of input and engagement with advocates.

Member of the Public - Faiza Ali

I think this is a conversation that needs to be had more broadly with other stakeholders, you know, to fully understand, you know, what will the impact be, in fact, if we were to transition into an agency or not.

Linda Lee

And is there, are there regular meetings or task force groups or conversations?