Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Lee and Tisch discuss enforcement of unsafe mobility devices

New York City Council · Jun 1, 2026 · starts 3:11:53 · 1 min 47 sec

Lee asks about enforcement of unsafe mobility devices like e-bikes and scooters. Tisch says it's a problem, criminal summonses are still issued for reckless driving, but the department has shifted from C summonses to B summonses for lesser violations based on City Hall conversations.

Linda Lee

And the final question is on the unsafe use of mobility devices.

Linda Lee

As we know, mobility devices such as e-bikes, scooters, mopeds, they're good.

Linda Lee

You could easily move around.

Linda Lee

They reduce traffic.

Linda Lee

They also reduce air pollution versus, for example, using cars.

Linda Lee

But we have seen people use them in an unsafe way.

Linda Lee

And, of course, very complex issue.

Linda Lee

It could be super difficult to enforce the rules.

Linda Lee

You stop them, they could easily take off, and it's difficult to, you know, engage in a high vehicle pursuit.

Linda Lee

And also they could obviously move much faster than other cars and enter areas that cars can't enter.

Linda Lee

Do you think the reckless use of these items are a problem?

Linda Lee

And if yes,

Linda Lee

What's the policy on this?

Jessica Tisch

So yes, I think it's a problem and I think that the data bears it out.

Jessica Tisch

I want to be clear that for reckless driving of these smaller mobility devices, we still today

Jessica Tisch

can issue criminal summonses for that, and we continue to issue criminal summonses for reckless use of e-bikes and scooters.

Jessica Tisch

But for other offenses, like for example, speeding or running a red light, things that come just short of

Jessica Tisch

recklessness, we, or the legal definition of recklessness,

Jessica Tisch

we have reverted from issuing C summonses to issuing B summonses based on conversations with City Hall.

Linda Lee

All right.

Linda Lee

Thank you for the information.

Linda Lee

I know my colleagues have a second round of questions, so I'll pause here.

Linda Lee

Thank you.

Jessica Tisch

Thank you.

Oswald J. Feliz

Okay.