Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Williams asks about hiring disparities and gender facility needs

New York City Council · Jun 1, 2026 · starts 4:59:21 · 3 min 38 sec

Williams asks about disparities in hiring, promotion, and retention. Noonan explains they focused on reachable test takers for the firefighter exam, with preliminary findings showing outcomes exceeding blueprint goals. Williams also asks about the home division rule and gender-related facility needs.

Nantasha M. Williams

Another question I have is, does FDNY, will you assess factors contributing to hiring, promotion, and retention of EMTs and firefighters across applicant demographics?

Nantasha M. Williams

By the end of 2026, that was something that you stated that you would do.

Nantasha M. Williams

So just wanted to know if you had any information on what disparities the department has already identified and what corrective actions are under consideration.

Nafisa Noonan

In terms of corrective actions, we did quite a bit of an analysis for the 23-24 campaign.

Nafisa Noonan

And we came up with a pretty sound blueprint that we used to work through the most recent campaign.

Nafisa Noonan

I'm sorry.

Nafisa Noonan

UBS campaign for the 23-24 campaign, 2026.

Nafisa Noonan

And a lot of what we found was that we needed to focus a bit more and not on just recruiting more people in general.

Nafisa Noonan

We wanted to focus more on our reachable test takers, specifically for our firefighter titles.

Nafisa Noonan

It's a very competitive title.

Nafisa Noonan

And just recruiting blindly and not focusing on where we're finding people that are actually able to pass the exam at a score that's reachable was essential to us.

Nafisa Noonan

And so what we did find in some of our preliminary findings is that

Nafisa Noonan

the outcome of the exam seems to be a bit more favorable than the goals that we set for the blueprint.

Nafisa Noonan

So we're pretty happy about that.

Nafisa Noonan

So our focus now is just making sure that we are providing attrition mitigation programs to make sure that the targeted audiences that we focused on reaching are able to pass the physical exam, make it through the hiring process, you know, pair with mentors and all the

Nafisa Noonan

programs that we offer to make sure that they make it through the process successfully.

Nantasha M. Williams

Okay.

Nantasha M. Williams

Also in your plan, you stated that the department will continue assigning probationary firefighters who reside in New York City to divisions where they live whenever operationally feasible.

Nantasha M. Williams

What is the rationale behind this initiative and how does FDNY believe it improves community trust or service delivery?

John Esposito

So that is what we consider the home division rule, where probies that live in the city are given the option to be assigned to a fire company in the division in which they reside.

John Esposito

And that was part of our settlement with the court more than 10 years ago.

John Esposito

There are times when due to staffing levels that it's not operationally feasible, and then they would be placed in a division, one of the divisions closer, which does not happen commonly.

John Esposito

Most of the time there, if they request the home division, they are granted the home division.

Nantasha M. Williams

Okay, just quickly two more quick questions.

Nantasha M. Williams

Just I want to talk about gender-related facility needs.

Nantasha M. Williams

So how frequently are borough commanders reviewing gender-related facility needs, and is there a centralized tracking system for unresolved issues?

Nantasha M. Williams

I know in some previous hearings that was a big complaint.

Nantasha M. Williams

Just making sure you have facilities for women.

John Esposito

I'm sorry, what was the second part of that?

Nantasha M. Williams

How frequently are borough commanders reviewing gender-related facility needs, and is there a centralized tracking system for unresolved issues?

John Esposito

So twice a year, the borough commanders have the mixed gender meetings where all the female firefighters are invited to come in and sit down with the borough commander.

John Esposito

And bring up any issues.

John Esposito

And for any facility,

John Esposito

These related problems, there is a resource center, the central reporting system, to track them.

John Esposito

So, yes, they are tracked.