Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Krishnan on staff retention, promotions, and OMB approval barriers

New York City Council · Jun 2, 2026 · starts 0:54:49 · 3 min 21 sec

Krishnan asks about staff retention and promotions. Shahada confirms DOI has no funding for promotions, OMB does not approve merit-based raises, and all retention efforts have been self-funded by reallocating vacancy funds. She describes a prior plan to address pay disparities among deputy inspector generals and create a promotional path for investigators, all funded by repurposing vacant position dollars.

Shekar Krishnan

And a few other questions that I have too before turning it over to our colleagues.

Shekar Krishnan

We touched on this a bit before, but when positions are affected, whether it's vacant lines or existing positions,

Shekar Krishnan

It doesn't seem to me, and as you testified to, the impacts are much broader than this, this specific number of positions on the table.

Shekar Krishnan

But it could actually affect staff retention, too, more broadly speaking.

Shekar Krishnan

Does the department have the funding to promote staff?

Shekar Krishnan

Are there opportunities for promotions, increases in salaries?

Shekar Krishnan

If not, are these requests you are working on to explore how to

Shekar Krishnan

Achieve that goal.

Shekar Krishnan

How do you think about staff retention more broadly?

Nadia Shihata

So I agree with you that promotion and growth opportunities are essential for hiring and retention.

Nadia Shihata

At this point, we do not have funding to promote staff.

Nadia Shihata

And it's my understanding that OMB does not approve merit-based promotions and raises.

Nadia Shihata

DOI has 25 vacancies as of May 27, 2026.

Nadia Shihata

However, we only have funding to support 16 of those vacancies.

Nadia Shihata

In the past, we have made requests to OMB for additional funding.

Nadia Shihata

In the past administration, we made such requests for promotions and staff retention, and we did not receive any funding from OMB.

Nadia Shihata

All of our retention efforts that DOI has made have been self-funded by reallocating resources from vacancies.

Nadia Shihata

And in the last administration, even though OMB did not allocate new funding for these efforts, the approval to be able to use our existing funding still took over a year to receive.

Nadia Shihata

We have, several years ago, DOI determined that our significant attrition in our investigative ranks was largely due to an absence of a path to promotion and salaries that are not competitive with other public sector

Nadia Shihata

opportunities or the private sector.

Nadia Shihata

And as a result, DOI implemented a plan that gave raises and promotions to individual confidential investigators based on merit to appropriately reflect each of their levels of experience, responsibility, and performance, and

Nadia Shihata

address pay disparity among our deputy inspector generals.

Nadia Shihata

All of whom generally did the same type of work, had similar expertise, and perform at comparable levels, but were paid at different salaries.

Nadia Shihata

And we created a clear promotional path for investigators.

Nadia Shihata

But again, this was, in order to do that, we had to repurpose funds from vacancies.

Nadia Shihata

So we did not receive additional funding for that.

Nadia Shihata

But clearly it's an issue, and we've tried to address it, but it's going to continue to be an issue, and we don't have additional funding to continue to be able to address it.

Shekar Krishnan

It's very concerning.

Shekar Krishnan

And I think, you know, for lack of a better word, it seems like the agency is robbing Peter to pay Paul.

Shekar Krishnan

In other words, using pulling from one area to keep staff and pay for increased salary needs in the other.

Shekar Krishnan

Isn't that the case?

Nadia Shihata

I think that's a good way of putting it.