Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Council Member Narcisse on pied-a-terre surcharge and seniors with fixed incomes

New York City Council · Jun 9, 2026 · starts 0:48:39 · 3 min 17 sec

Narcisse asks if DOF is ready to administer the pied-a-terre surcharge and how it affects seniors on fixed incomes. Commissioner Lee confirms DOF expects to meet the $500 million revenue target, and Shear clarifies the surcharge applies to second homes of non-residents, with payment plans available for those facing difficulty.

Mercedes Narcisse

my time is limited if there is a pay to tear surcharge moves ahead is finance ready to administer it and what does it expected to collect

Mercedes Narcisse

from your time and how does finance um through i mean treat a senior in a fixed income whose home value has soared on paper but whose income has not uh moved at all

Richard Lee

so the um we are currently in the implement

Richard Lee

implementation stages of the P.A.

Richard Lee

De Terre surcharge, and we are confident that we will be able to meet the revenue target of $500 million as a part that was included as part of the executive plan.

Richard Lee

I'm sorry, your second part of that question was?

Mercedes Narcisse

What do you do?

Mercedes Narcisse

How do you move?

Mercedes Narcisse

Like you're talking about the last one I'm interested in.

Mercedes Narcisse

The income whose home value soared, but now the income is fixed.

Mercedes Narcisse

They don't have no budget increase.

Mercedes Narcisse

So how do you work with that?

Richard Lee

Yeah, so just to outline the contours of the program, right now the program is specifically designed so that for class one properties, those that are valued between five and 15 million

Richard Lee

will see a surcharge rate of about 0.8% for 15 to 25 million and 1.05 and 25 million plus on their class one market value will receive a 1.3% surcharge.

Richard Lee

For those who are in co-ops and condos, we have a similar sort of structure of one to three at 4%, three to five at 5.25, and five million at 6.5.

Richard Lee

We don't necessarily directly look at personal income.

Richard Lee

Our first deputy commissioner is going to oversee the implementation phases of the Peter Tear Tax.

Richard Lee

I'm happy to have him maybe elaborate on some of the implementation that we have to do and the case of this.

Jeffrey Shear

Yes, so two other points that I want to make is first just

Jeffrey Shear

To emphasize the nature of the pied-a-terre surcharge.

Jeffrey Shear

So this is on people who own two or more homes.

Jeffrey Shear

Yes.

Jeffrey Shear

Second.

Jeffrey Shear

Second home.

Jeffrey Shear

Right, second home.

Jeffrey Shear

So if it's someone and they are cash poor and their home has soared in value, we understand that.

Jeffrey Shear

We do want to make sure people understand that it would need to be their second home where they are not a resident.

Jeffrey Shear

The other point that I would like to make on this is that we do offer payment plans.

Jeffrey Shear

So if we have someone in that situation and they have a surcharge and they are having difficulty paying it, we can offer a payment plan to them.

Mercedes Narcisse

But they're period here.

Mercedes Narcisse

But regular seniors, I want you all to pay attention to that because a lot of them having difficulty holding their home.

Mercedes Narcisse

And if there's anything that flag, if it's in my district, I want to know because I want to help.

Mercedes Narcisse

We're happy.

Richard Lee

If there are any instances that are coming up that you see where we have secondary homeowners in this situation, we're happy to work with them on any sort of programs that we might have and assist in any way.

Richard Lee

So just feel free to reach out to our office.

Mercedes Narcisse

Thank you, Mr.

Mercedes Narcisse

Commissioner.

Mercedes Narcisse

You can still bother him.

Mercedes Narcisse

You can still go bother him.

Mercedes Narcisse

Okay.

Mercedes Narcisse

Councilmember Wong, follow right, Brewer.