Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Camacho CB4 chair opposes term limits and politicization

New York City Council · Jun 22, 2026 · starts 2:02:45 · 6 min 19 sec

Robert Camacho, chair of Brooklyn CB4 for 42 years, passionately opposes term limits for both board members and district managers, saying he is being forced out despite dedicating decades to his community. He argues the bills would politicize boards and that existing processes already allow removal of non-performing members.

Robert Camacho

Hello, Chairperson Brewer.

Robert Camacho

And members of the committee.

Robert Camacho

My name is Robert Camacho.

Robert Camacho

I'm the chair of Community Board 4.

Robert Camacho

I'm Celeste DeLeon's boss.

Robert Camacho

I don't call her my boss, I call her my friend.

Robert Camacho

I have been on the board for 42 years, since I was 23, I'm 65.

Robert Camacho

I became the chair in 2018.

Robert Camacho

I am term limited in 2027.

Robert Camacho

What the board means to me, I've been advocating for my community.

Robert Camacho

Ever since, nobody wanted to live in my community.

Robert Camacho

We were infected with drugs, dope, bushwhip was burning, and no one wanted to be there.

Robert Camacho

And now they want to turn someone like me out.

Robert Camacho

I still live there.

Robert Camacho

Another important, how to speak out.

Robert Camacho

Volunteers.

Robert Camacho

That's their job.

Robert Camacho

You want the job submitted, an application, let them do the work.

Robert Camacho

And if they can't do the work,

Robert Camacho

That's the responsibility and address to the board.

Robert Camacho

There are already term limits for board members now.

Robert Camacho

They want to introduce term limits for district managers.

Robert Camacho

Yet there is no bill to assure members who are volunteer represented to the manager city staff.

Robert Camacho

The borough presidents are doing different things

Robert Camacho

One HR does this, one doesn't do that.

Robert Camacho

You always want to take away the board's job as an independent agency to give the borough president the title to terminate a city employee at will.

Robert Camacho

That cannot be legal.

Robert Camacho

The manager is hired by the board, and the board is the only responsibility for addressing the issue before terminating an employee.

Robert Camacho

This will prioritize or likely further politicize the board's discouraged candidates.

Robert Camacho

From the position, and guess what?

Robert Camacho

Weakens the board ability to terminate.

Robert Camacho

Conduct business.

Robert Camacho

Board members gone.

Robert Camacho

Just reminders gone.

Robert Camacho

What do we do?

Robert Camacho

Maybe at least encourage new ideas and respective of what happens to people that are underrepresented.

Robert Camacho

What happens when we're pushed out?

Robert Camacho

The bill for council members appointed like the borough president.

Robert Camacho

It might help, or again, it depends.

Robert Camacho

It's 2026.

Robert Camacho

Why aren't they considering other options like the priest and community council do?

Robert Camacho

You sign in.

Robert Camacho

And that's how every year they put X amount of people that come in to the meeting.

Robert Camacho

So if they meet 10 times a year, you have to have X amount of percentage.

Robert Camacho

And then the peers vote them in that are there.

Robert Camacho

I know you know the procedure very well.

Robert Camacho

And it won't be politicalized because they didn't do their job.

Robert Camacho

I'm getting turned out.

Robert Camacho

So they needed to do their job because I represent my community, love my community.

Robert Camacho

I'm getting charmed out because they didn't do theirs.

Robert Camacho

So their point, it looked like it's political to me.

Robert Camacho

So if you're not part of the clique or you don't agree with them, then they turn me around and say, we don't need you now.

Robert Camacho

But when the...

Robert Camacho

The place was burning down and no one was living there.

Robert Camacho

Or the sun, now they need members.

Robert Camacho

It took me almost a year myself volunteering to get 13 board members to get on the board.

Robert Camacho

A year.

Robert Camacho

I've been getting rid of board members that hasn't been coming to meetings and we haven't had quorum.

Robert Camacho

I've been doing my job.

Robert Camacho

Now I'm the bad guy because I did my job and he says, oh, three minutes.

Robert Camacho

We need quorum and we need, if you want to work for this community and help this community, we need you here.

Robert Camacho

We don't need you home.

Robert Camacho

And I did that.

Robert Camacho

And if you look it up on the Brooklyn Borough Project, you'll know everyone that I terminated with the board.

Robert Camacho

With their recommendation in regards that they haven't been coming or we don't have quorum to do.

Robert Camacho

Also, before I end there, I also...

Robert Camacho

We need to scrutinize also the borough presidents in regards appointments.

Robert Camacho

Because now we're having people with personal agendas because they're part of this clique, part of that clique, and part of that clique.

Robert Camacho

When all the time I'm constantly got to tell them it has to be for the community.

Robert Camacho

Every community is different.

Robert Camacho

Every area is different.

Robert Camacho

So you have to work and have the public's opinion, the people that live there, and that's going to impact that area or whatever it is they want, them and not their personal agenda or being biased.

Robert Camacho

And that's what we're getting.

Robert Camacho

So please don't let this go.

Robert Camacho

My district manager, I always thought she was a gentrifier.

Robert Camacho

It's funny.

Robert Camacho

I tell this to everybody.

Robert Camacho

I see this young girl, and then I realize...

Robert Camacho

That when I seen this man that was there was her dad.

Robert Camacho

I didn't know it was her dad.

Robert Camacho

I grew up with her dad.

Robert Camacho

Her grandfather used to teach me baseball.

Gale A. Brewer

You've got to wrap up a little bit, but go ahead.

Robert Camacho

So I want to make sure that she knows our community very well because she does.

Robert Camacho

And we want to make sure that our managers that are here continue to stay here.

Gale A. Brewer

I agree.