Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Morano questions Micah on flag meaning and symbolism

New York City Council · Jun 22, 2026 · starts 2:22:28 · 3 min 6 sec

Morano asks Micah why a flag matters and about potentially controversial symbolism. Micah explains the flag's allegorical content: Henry Hudson's ship the Half Moon, indigenous people greeting him, a figure representing the city with a downward-pointing sword indicating peace, and turtle doves that mate for life on the shield.

Frank Morano

I have one question for Mr.

Frank Morano

Micah on the flag and then one question for the community board panel.

Frank Morano

Mr.

Frank Morano

Micah, one, thank you not only for being here today and spending hours here and waiting to testify and give some of the perspective and the history of the flag.

Frank Morano

I have a two-part question.

Frank Morano

One is...

Frank Morano

What does it matter what flag a borough has?

Frank Morano

Staten Islanders still have to pay the same taxes.

Frank Morano

They still have to deal with the same problems with cost of living and crime and sanitation and everything.

Frank Morano

Who cares what kind of flag that we have?

Frank Morano

And second, a lot of my colleagues in the council, because of concerns about how things used to be in the 17th century, 18th century, 19th century,

Frank Morano

18th century and evolving trends of treatment of American Indian groups, for instance, and numerous other groups that were formerly mistreated by European colonial settlers.

Frank Morano

They wonder what actually is in this flag and is there somebody or something in this flag that might be controversial.

Frank Morano

I'm wondering if you can actually explain some of the symbolism, some of the images in the flag itself so my colleagues know what they're voting on.

Member of the Public - Micah

Sure.

Member of the Public - Micah

We liked very much the original seal for its allegorical content.

Member of the Public - Micah

And that is to say, Henry Hudson came into the Narrows in 1609.

Member of the Public - Micah

So his ship, the Half Moon, is portrayed there.

Member of the Public - Micah

He was greeted by indigenous people.

Member of the Public - Micah

Staten Islanders.

Member of the Public - Micah

It wasn't Staten Island yet, but they were farmers and fishermen who greeted him.

Member of the Public - Micah

This figure, again, an allegorical figure, represents the city.

Member of the Public - Micah

Her sword is pointed down, indicating peace.

Member of the Public - Micah

Her shield contains two turtle doves who mate for life.

Member of the Public - Micah

So we thought there was great value in the imagery.

Member of the Public - Micah

It just needed to be brought into contemporary feeling.

Member of the Public - Micah

And so that...

Member of the Public - Micah

And to what you asked for, I've been privileged to work as an art director and graphic designer all my life, most recently for the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

Member of the Public - Micah

It has always been my goal in doing my work to communicate ideas.

Member of the Public - Micah

And for Staten Island to be proud of a flag that represents us, I think, has value.

Member of the Public - Micah

And so if we can bring it up to a level that somebody can look at and say, yeah, I feel good about that, then I think that was the purpose.