Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Arianna Rebellini on human teachers and the humanities

New York City Council · Jun 24, 2026 · starts 4:25:54 · 2 min 56 sec

Rebellini, a writer and mother, shares stories of her father's 43-year teaching career and the immeasurable impact teachers have that machines cannot replicate. She cites her own book about suicide to emphasize the consequences of losing human connection, noting black children are especially susceptible to isolation, and calls chatbots used as study guides harmful.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Thank you.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I certainly wouldn't want my kids becoming losers.

Member of the Public - Greg Pak

No, you don't.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I think you are learning something from our president.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

I'm calling people losers.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Okay, please.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Thank you, chairs.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

I'm Arianna Rebellini.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

I'm a mother to a soon-to-be second grader in Queens and a writer.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

And I want to speak today about...

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

My entire life, I've had people tell me my father changed their lives.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Carlo taught high school English for 43 impassioned years, and if there's one thing I know beyond all doubt, it is that my father loved teaching and his students loved him.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

When he retired, we set up a website where former students could leave well wishes, and it was a gift to see what they had each held on to.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

From high fives in the hallways to a new respect for reading.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

My dad was born and raised in what he loves to call the boogie down Bronx, and rap has been a huge part of his life and syllabi.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Multiple posts shouted out Wu-Tang Wednesday and Kendrick Friday.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

And I say all of this to highlight the varied and immeasurable impact of teachers.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

And the incalculable losses we in our community will endure if we declare them redundant in the face of AI.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

If my father changed his students'lives, it was in ways that can't be replicated by a machine.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

It is something living and indelible and unpredictable.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

I can't believe I need to say this, but educators should be people.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Anyone who cares about children's well-being knows that.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

I know you know that.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

I know the DOE knows that.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

This is a disingenuous conversation.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Last year, I published a book about suicide, so I feel uniquely qualified to emphasize the dire emotional and material consequences of losing human connection.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Isolation and alienation are killing us, and I must note that black children are especially susceptible.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Chatbots, which we are already seeing being used as study guides and tutors, are certainly not helping.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Our children cannot afford to lose even one person who is invested in their future.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

I want to close with one message from my father.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

She wrote, your classroom is not just where I learned how to write essays or identify sentences, but it was where I learned how to be human.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

So when we talk about how AI is destroying the humanities, we're describing not only academics, but more profoundly the very substance of life.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

It is your responsibility to protect our children's right to both, and the moratorium will be a good start.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Thank you.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

You say your dad's from the Bronx?

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Yeah, he is.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Both parents.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Both parents?

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Yeah.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Now you've got to tell me where in the Bronx.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Allerton Avenue was what they were near.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

I was born in the Bronx, but...

Carmen N. De La Rosa

You were born in the Bronx.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

You know, you're welcome back anytime.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Thank you.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

All right.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Awesome.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Thank you.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Thank you to this panel.

Member of the Public - Arianna Rebellini

Thank you.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Okay, I'm going to call the next panel Iman God.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Charlotte Pope.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Andrea Ortiz.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Anita Rad.

Member of the Public - Andrea Ortiz

I'll let you all decide.

Member of the Public - Andrea Ortiz

Fielder's choice.