Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Councilmember Cabán questions NYPD on desk appearance ticket denial documentation

New York City Council · Jun 25, 2026 · starts 1:48:09 · 2 min 11 sec

Cabán asks about NYPD policy on documenting reasons for denying DATs and whether DAT investigation forms are still used. The NYPD representative says this is an operational decision outside his scope but offers to follow up with data.

Selvena N. Brooks-Powers

I'm going to pass it to Councilmember Caban.

Tiffany L. Cabán

Thank you.

Tiffany L. Cabán

My questions are for the NYPD.

Tiffany L. Cabán

I want to start by sort of the role that NYPD has in relation to the production of people that are in the system.

Tiffany L. Cabán

Just like the DAs have a lot of control in this area, so does the NYPD.

Tiffany L. Cabán

And unfortunately, we're seeing...

Tiffany L. Cabán

What is, can unequivocally be described as a drastic increase in broken windows policing, which again, there is well over two decades of research that says this stuff does not bear

Tiffany L. Cabán

any progress on public safety.

Tiffany L. Cabán

But I want to know about the NYPD's current policy on documenting the reason a DAT was denied.

Tiffany L. Cabán

You know, my understanding is that you guys maybe aren't using DAT investigation forms anymore, which those are the documents that include a lot of the exceptions that aren't in the statute.

Tiffany L. Cabán

But based on the information that I've been getting from folks who work with people in the system, and based on my questioning at previous hearings,

Tiffany L. Cabán

This does not seem to be what's actually happening.

Tiffany L. Cabán

So can you lay out exactly what the policy is around the document?

Tiffany L. Cabán

of the reason a DAT or an appearance ticket was denied.

Member of the Public - NYPD Representative

Councilmember, I appreciate that.

Member of the Public - NYPD Representative

Unfortunately, I think you're discussing or talking about an operational decision that is essentially occurring in a command by a uniformed member of service.

Member of the Public - NYPD Representative

I think it's a little, it is outside of the scope that I'm able to attest to here today.

Tiffany L. Cabán

I mean, how many people are going before a judge and how many people are being processed rather getting an appearance ticket, I think falls under the scope of an oversight hearing of