Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Janice Brody, Clayton Apartments board member, testifies on deficits and need for grants not loans

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 2:46:16 · 3 min 57 sec

Brody describes Clayton Apartments' $15,000/month deficit, $700K insurance costs, and $25M+ in needed repairs, arguing Mitchell-Lamas should be treated as infrastructure receiving capital grants rather than loans that add to debt.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

You want to go first?

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

Because the two of us are together.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

I'm a board member for Clayton Apartments, located in Harlem, Central Harlem, on West 135th Street.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

Currently, our co-op, we're running at a deficit, at least $15,000 a month.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We do have an IPNA.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

In process, but it looks like we may need between $25 million or more to get our building up to standard.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We do have something in the process we need to get.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

I mean, we had a grant for like $150,000, but it turned out we can't get that unless we flip over another loan first.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

So we got to get into debt further just to get a six figure that we want to use for our double breaks for the elevator.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We have to get that done by January 27.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

So we're constantly.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

operating in a deficit.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

And when I listened here earlier to, we're talking about in 27 and 28, we're going to have all this money and capital funding.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

And you just kind of broke it down by saying, it's going to be a loan.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

It's not going to be an investment.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We need investment.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

I mean, I think you need to look at the Mitchell Llamas as being part of the city infrastructure.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We should be treated as, we shouldn't be treated as, I don't know, debt.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We're being treated as debt.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

And basically right now, as far as, I mean, we went through a lot of numbers.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

I'm just going to throw a couple at you.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

Our insurance, $700,000 a year.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We do have a lot of seniors.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

The scree, that's not even a Band-Aid.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

I don't know what it's going to cover.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

But when we look at where we're located, there's going to be one big project that's going to have over 1,000 apartments.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

It's called 1-145 on 145th Street in Lenox.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

You're giving them big tax breaks.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

There's going to be another building, three buildings across the street from us.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

Big tax breaks, but we got to go into debt.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

So what we're asking for, we're not asking for a loan.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We're asking you to come in, say it's capital, and help repair our building.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We don't need another loan.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We don't need a balloon coming.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

And we got balloons already.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

My building is 62 years old.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

So we are ready.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We've been turning over and turning over.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

And over till we can't turn over no more.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We need help, and I'm trying to make sure I'm covering everything because I didn't know I had two minutes.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

So, yeah, Ms.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

Sanchez earlier mentioned the breaks that the renters are getting, the tax breaks.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

The co-ops are not getting any breaks.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

And like I said, we got to repair the elevator by 2027.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

All these local laws, Fairfield Avenue co-ops, they said they was going to put together a petition, and they sent one to you.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We're going to get a petition going to these local laws.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

Y'all should be covering them.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

Sorry.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

Our rent can only cover operating.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We can't cover the local laws.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

It's just a little bit too much.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

And I'm trying to go through all the figures of everything that we owe.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

But we need to be treated like we're infrastructure.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

And when you say capital, say capital.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

If it's a loan, then be true and say it's a loan.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

Because I was like, oh, yeah, we're getting all this money, 27, 28.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

And then you broke it down, and it's really a loan.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

We are ready in debt.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

So this is another board member.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

So I'm going to stop now and let him.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

Did I cover everything?

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

Okay.

Member of the Public - Janice Brody

Thank you.