Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Delmar Leon (Canine Rescue NYC) testifies with incident timeline

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 7:56:15 · 2 min 49 sec

Delmar Leon of Canine Rescue NYC testifies supporting the ban, listing decades of specific carriage incidents from 1982 to 2016, and argues the pattern demonstrates an industry with little oversight showing neglect.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

Thank you, Chairman and Council Members, for prioritizing this matter.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

My name is Delmar Leon, founder of Canine Rescue NYC.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

I believe the compounded numbers of accidents that have occurred over three decades on an ongoing basis only points to an industry who has been overlooked with little oversight while consistently showing neglect based on the numbers of accidents we have seen

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

for decades, which culminated into the tragedy that called for its suspension after the death of Ramond.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

A precedent needs to be made.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

Be sad with the death of Ramant, whom I take this opportunity to offer my condolences to the Mahajan's family.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

This bill is not about removing the passion for riding your horse, as was heard by one panelist's testimony, but removing them from riding on the streets of New York City and Central Park.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

We also heard earlier from their main veterinary, there is no standard policy in place to ensure their animal's well-being is being maintained.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

Assessment of the horse health is left to be determined by the horse rider or owner, and the horse owner or rider also decides when to call the vet.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

How are we ensuring the driver that horse that day will be looking out for the animal's welfare?

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

If it may mean no income for that day or week.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

We also heard earlier how council members had yet to be called back to schedule a meeting and only did so after weeks, which allows time to correct and or cover up any deficiencies before the time comes for visit.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

The horse carriage drivers mentioned horses are a creature of habits, yet there is a pattern of accidents showing that in 30 years, horses have yet to get used and accustomed to riding on the streets of New York City and Central Park.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

1982, three horses collapse and die on the streets in July, including Malachi.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

November 1986, riding horse taking off and crashing into building.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

May 1988, a horse failing into manhole.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

May 1990, a horse being fatally pinned between a bus and a car.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

January 2006, a five-year-old gelding named Spotty spooks bolt into traffic and wraps himself over the top of a station wagon.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

The horse breaks in leg and dies, becoming a major catalyst for organized campaigns to ban New York City horses.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

April 2014, a carriage horse is pinned to the ground in an overturned carriage.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

after being spooked by a bus.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

Two years later, in January 2016, Spartacus spooks.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

I would like to conclude.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

It is time to ban carriage.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

Horses out of the streets of New York City and Central Park.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

This incident only demonstrates an industry that has been overlooked with a little oversight showing a pattern that has been overlooked.

Council Staff

Thank you.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

To conclude, just one little thing.

Council Staff

Your time is up.

Council Staff

Thank you so much.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

May I just finalize this last thing?

Council Staff

Go ahead.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

I would like to conclude by stating that I'm in favor of Romance Riders Bill 1943, bringing attention to a similar matter happening within the animal shelter system and

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

NYC ACC, also left with no oversight and accountability, leaving an inhumane confinement, highly medicated, and ensure that they can cope with the inhumane shelter environment.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

This couple of weeks alone, they have doubled up in killings.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

Thank you so much.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

Schedule oversight hearing on NYC ACC.

Member of the Public - Delmar Leon

Thank you so much.

Council Staff

Thank you.

Council Staff

Next.