Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Edie Falco testifies in support of ban

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 2:14:59 · 2 min 29 sec

Actress and animal advocate Edie Falco testifies that animals are not ours to use, expresses horror at carriage conditions, and says naming the law for Romanch is the greatest honor of her lifetime.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

Hi, my name is Edie Falco.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

I am an actress and I'm an animal lover and advocate.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

For some reason, I was asked to be here today to tell people how I feel about this.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

And I think I'm going to go way out on a limb here and say from the deepest part of my heart,

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

These animals are not ours.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

These animals are not ours.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

They are not put on this planet to do our bidding.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

They're not for us to look at and say, oh, that one's going to pull me through the park, and this one I'm going to eat, and this one I'm going to wear, and this one I'm going to experiment on for drugs.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

You know, this is the wrong meeting for this perhaps, but insofar as my animal advocacy, these are not our animals.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

They have the right to a God-given, if that's what you believe, life just as we do.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

I have a fantasy of us looking back on this in 200 years and saying, remember that when we had those big, beautiful, majestic animals pulling us on carriages?

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

The fact that there's anybody in this room that can look at an animal with the apparatus and the carriage and the people in the traffic and the sounds and the smells and the heat and say, sure, yeah, that's reasonable.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

The first time I saw that 40 years ago, I thought, what is this?

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

It's 40 years later.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

I've looked face to face with politicians in this city since then who have said, no, we're on it, we're on it.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

It's our platform.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

We're going to make it happen.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

To be here, I'm going to say very quickly, I'm an empath.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

It's what I do for a living, and I can't always turn it off.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

And to listen to the Romantics family and what they are going through knocked the wind out of me.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

I have an 18-year-old, and I came to this city as an 18-year-old with dreams and a life to start.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

It's 40 years later, and I've lived that dream 4,000 times over, and that I am here with the honor of potentially naming this law.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

For Romant, for the future he will not have and the dreams he will not get to realize, is the greatest honor of my lifetime.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

It's time, everybody.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

It's time.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

It's time.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

You can't pretend that you don't know what you know.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

That's it.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

Sorry.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

Thank you.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

No, thank you very much.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

Bob Holden, Mr.

Member of the Public - Edie Falco

Holden.