Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Kathleen Reb (SPCA International) testifies supporting ban

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 7:52:27 · 1 min 41 sec

Kathleen Reb of SPCA International testifies supporting the ban, citing recent tragedies including Denise's death and Romanch's killing, and noting Philadelphia's recent vote to end carriage rides.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

Kathleen Reb, members of the council, thank you for the opportunity to speak today on behalf of SPCA International about an issue that directly impacts animal welfare and the safety of all people in our city.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

We are here today because it is time that New York City move beyond horse-drawn carriages.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

This is an outdated practice that puts both horses and people at risk.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

Our cities are busier than ever, filled with traffic, construction, noise, and countless hazards that were never designed for large animals.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

Yet horses are still expected to navigate in these conditions every day.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

Recent tragedies have underscored these concerns within a matter of weeks.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

Another carriage horse collapsed and died.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

A man lost his life in an incident involving a horse-drawn carriage.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

These heartbreaking events remind us that the status quo is not without consequences.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

Cities are beginning to recognize that there is a better way.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

Just last month, Philadelphia voted to end horse-drawn carriage rides, demonstrating that communities can prevent their history while embracing safer and more humane alternatives.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

New York has long been a leader in advancing animal welfare.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

We have the opportunity to once again lead with compassion by ending an outdated practice that no longer reflects the values of our city.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

We urge the council to support Ramont's law.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

that phases out horse-drawn carriages and prioritizes the safety and well-being of both New Yorkers and the horses who deserve a safer life.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

Let's be on the right side of history for our communities and for the animals who depend on us.

Member of the Public - Kathleen Reb

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you.