Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Naveed Margaret (aunt) testifies about family's grief

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 0:26:12 · 2 min 26 sec

Naveed Margaret, Romanch's aunt, testifies about the family's grief, the silence in their home, and urges the council to pass the ban so no other family experiences this nightmare.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

My name is Naveed Margaret, and I'm Romance's aunt.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

I came here today with a broken heart because our beautiful boy is gone.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

And where he used to be, there is now a silence I cannot describe.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

Before this, Romance was a sunshine.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

I know every family says that.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

But I need you to hear it about him.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

Charming, loving, full of life.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

18 years old, celebrating his graduation with every dream still in front of him.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

He trusted the city.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

He got into the carriage believing that if New York allowed these rides on its streets, they must be safe.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

That trust is what makes this unbearable.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

A happy family trip turned into pure terror when the force became wild and uncontrollable.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

And in those last moments, my nephew was so brave, braver than any child should ever have to be, facing something like that.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

Never should have been allowed to happen to him.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

Every day since the quiet in our home is deafening.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

Some mornings the grief is so heavy.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

It is hard to take a breath.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

I look at the empty space where romance should be and the weight of it sits on my chest and does not move.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

Please do not let him become a case number on a piece of paper.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

If you have children or a niece or a nephew, take off them tonight.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

Imagine that fear for one second and then follow your heart.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

The horse-drawn carriage ban must come to an end, which is why Romand's death was preventable and why only a ban will do.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

Pass Romand's law immediately.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

Please help us spare the next family from this nightmare.

Member of the Public - Naveed Margaret

Thank you.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you very much.

Lynn C. Schulman

Now I'll call up Anuj Thukrat and Sovia Thukrat.

Lynn C. Schulman

You're here, right?

Lynn C. Schulman

Come up to the table.

Council Staff

No, he's got to go.