Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Schulman questions on horse removals and stable violations

New York City Council · Jul 15, 2026 · starts 0:51:38 · 2 min 42 sec

Schulman asks about horses removed from service for medical concerns, stable violation counts, and inspection staff. Schiff says six inspectors work on this among other duties and promises to provide violation data.

Lynn C. Schulman

Over the past five years, how many horses have been removed from service due to medical concerns?

Corinne Schiff

So it is a very routine process for us to take in complaints, often by video,

Corinne Schiff

to make observations ourselves, or to take in referrals from NYPD, which is often at the hack stands.

Corinne Schiff

And we will, depending on our veterinarian's assessment of those, we will require the owner to have its veterinarian assess the horse.

Corinne Schiff

And during that time, the horse is not in service.

Corinne Schiff

And we require the veterinarian to, the owner to provide the veterinarian's determination before the horse can be returned to work.

Corinne Schiff

I do not have the count.

Corinne Schiff

We can continue to work on that to try to provide it.

Lynn C. Schulman

We want the count, so we want you to get that to us.

Lynn C. Schulman

And I want to know what are the most common concerns that lead to removal.

Corinne Schiff

I can say some of the common concerns would be that the horse is lame, for example, and we might see a video that either shows that it is or that it needs further assessment to be able to determine that.

Corinne Schiff

That would be a common consideration.

Lynn C. Schulman

Okay.

Lynn C. Schulman

DOHMH is responsible for enforcing requirements governing stable conditions including adequate heating and ventilation, sufficient food and drinking water, and minimum stall dimensions.

Lynn C. Schulman

Over the past five years, how many violations has DOHMH issued for failure to comply with stable requirements?

Lynn C. Schulman

And please provide a breakdown by violation type.

Lynn C. Schulman

If you don't have it here, then you need to send it to us.

Lynn C. Schulman

Answer whatever you can answer right now.

Corinne Schiff

We do make routine inspections of the stables two to three times a year.

Corinne Schiff

I don't have the violation numbers, so we will get back to you.

Lynn C. Schulman

Okay.

Lynn C. Schulman

How many staff does the OHMH currently employ to inspect and oversee horse carriage stables?

Corinne Schiff

We have six health inspectors who work in our veterinary public health program.

Corinne Schiff

They do a variety of work, including the inspections of the horse carriages, and we have equine veterinarians we work with on a contract basis.

Lynn C. Schulman

Have any stables repeatedly failed inspections or required corrective action plans?

Corinne Schiff

The stables have not.

Corinne Schiff

required corrective action plans.

Lynn C. Schulman

Okay.