Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Q&A on BSA nominee John Manchin and council housing concerns

New York City Council · Aug 13, 2026 · starts 2:02:09 · 1 min 25 sec

Menin addresses concerns about BSA nominee John Manchin, noting some council members have raised concerns about his prior statements on community benefit agreements. She emphasizes the Council is pro-housing, having approved every ULURP and over 7,000 housing units, and looks forward to meeting Manchin.

Unidentified speaker

Hi.

Unidentified speaker

Happy to talk about it.

Unidentified speaker

And then I'm also going to ask our land use chair, Kevin Riley, and our majority whip and deputy speaker if they have anything to add on this.

Unidentified speaker

So first of all, I've not met with John Manchin.

Unidentified speaker

He has not reached out yet for a meeting.

Unidentified speaker

I look forward to meeting with him.

Unidentified speaker

What we have heard from many council members are concerns about some of his prior statements.

Unidentified speaker

I want to be clear.

Unidentified speaker

We are a pro-housing council.

Unidentified speaker

This council has approved every single ULERP that has come before it.

Unidentified speaker

We have approved over 7,000 units of housing, over 3,000 of which are affordable.

Unidentified speaker

So, again, any candidate to lead the BSA that will get our support must be adamantly pro-housing.

Unidentified speaker

What I think has happened in this situation, and this is why it's important to have advice and consent, is some members have raised some concerns about past writings of Mr.

Unidentified speaker

Manchin that refer to community benefit agreements and other things that members have concerns about.

Unidentified speaker

And so that will be the point of our hearing.

Unidentified speaker

That's the point of advice and consent, where there are questions, we raise them, we meet with the nominee, and we get our questions answered.

Unidentified speaker

Let me turn it over to Councilmember Riley.