Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Dave Backer testifies in support of tax for school funding and child care

New York City Council · Aug 18, 2026 · starts 1:42:57 · 1 min 58 sec

Dave Backer, a parent and school finance professor, supports the surcharge and argues the real problem is the property tax system's structure. He notes 43% of school funding comes from property taxes and that single-family homeowners pay 2.4 times less than multifamily dwellers.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

Hi, Council.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

My name is Dave Backer.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

I'm a parent of a six-year-old who's going to first grade at PS20 in Brooklyn, and a nine-month-old who I'm hoping will go to 2K after that.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

I'm also a co-op owner, and I was excited about the rollout of this surcharge.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

I didn't feel fear.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

I didn't feel nervousness.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

I didn't feel any panic.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

At all.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

In fact, I was excited about it, and I was excited about it for a lot of the reasons that the last speaker just said.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

I happen to be a professor of school finance as well, and I know that the real problem

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

here is not necessarily the rollout, but the way that the property tax system is structured and the way in which our kids'schooling and child care is all reliant upon it.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

This real problem, 43% of the money that goes to our kids'schools and child care comes from revenues brought in from property.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

Now, we have a trillion dollars of market value in this city that we could tax, but we're only at about a fifth of it in what we actually assess.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

We're falling short there.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

Single family homeowners, as the last speaker just mentioned, actually already pay 2.4 times less in their effective tax rate than multifamily dwellers.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

So my partner and I actually moved out of New York City.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

We went to a more affordable city.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

We had our daughter, and when we heard that pre-K was...

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

coming out, we were like, wow.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

We looked at the numbers, and it turned out we could save $60,000 a year by moving back to New York City.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

So we moved back.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

We came back.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

And we want that for everybody in this city, and we want to keep building on it.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

I don't know.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

I think the wealthy homeowners here doth protest a little too much.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

And I really hope that this debate, quote unquote, actually doesn't get in the way of much needed revenue in the city.

Member of the Public - Dave Backer

Thank you.

Member of the Public - Anna Champany

Thank you.