Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Laila Pinaranda testifies in support of tax for CUNY and public services

New York City Council · Aug 18, 2026 · starts 1:44:55 · 2 min 17 sec

Laila Pinaranda, a CUNY staff member and union member, supports the tax arguing housing should be for living, not parking wealth. She urges the council to stand with public sector workers and ensure the wealthiest contribute to public institutions like CUNY.

Member of the Public - Anna Champany

Next.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

Good afternoon, Chair and members of the City Council.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

My name is Laila Pinaranda, and I'm here today as a worker, a co-op resident, and a public sector union member to speak in support of the Piedad Terra tax.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

Today, we stand under the emblem, a government of the people, for the people, by the people, a principle which should hopefully inform today's hearing.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

I am a full-time CUNY staff member, a member of the PSC CUNY Union, a researcher at the CUNY Research Foundation, and a CUNY alum.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

Everything I am, I am thanks to CUNY and public education institutions of New York City.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

CUNY, as well as many public services, are the infrastructure that makes private and commonwealth possible.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

The question before us is simple.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

Who should pay for that infrastructure?

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

I believe those who have accumulated the greatest wealth

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

should contribute the greatest share.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

That is not an attack, contrary to what we've heard today, on ordinary homeowners.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

It is a recognition that housing should be a place to live, not simply another vehicle for accumulating and parking wealth.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

As a CUNY worker, I see every day what public investment makes possible.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

CUNY is one

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

of the great democratic institutions of New York.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

It gives working class New Yorkers like myself access to education, research, economic opportunity.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

But higher education has been asked to do more and more while operating under enormous financial pressure.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

And CUNY is only one example.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

Our public institutions are the common wealth of the city.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

We should reject the idea that government must constantly make working class people choose between the services that allow for dignified life and other basic necessities.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

The wealth exists.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

Today's city council hearing asks, are we visionary, bold, and courageous enough to organize our tax system so that wealth contributes to the society that produces and sustains it?

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

I urge the city council to stand with public sector workers and stand with CUNY.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

City council, stand for the principle that the wealthiest among us should pay their fair share.

Member of the Public - Laila Pinaranda

Thank you.