Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Ung Q&A: Mangin on council legal authority and disregarding local concerns

New York City Council · Sep 1, 2026 · starts 1:41:05 · 1 min 2 sec

Ung asks whether the Council has legal authority to require BSA transparency improvements and whether it's fair to disregard community concerns. Mangin commits to the improvements without needing legislation and says local voices are paramount even if not always decisive.

Sandra Ung

Do you believe, and since you're committing to it, but if somehow it doesn't happen, do you believe the council has legal authority to require the BSA to do that?

John Mangin

Thank you for the question.

John Mangin

I'm not totally sure.

John Mangin

I don't want to be answering legal questions that may implicate charter issues on the fly.

John Mangin

I commit to doing it.

John Mangin

And I'd have to get back to you on any of the legal questions.

Sandra Ung

Sure.

Sandra Ung

Let's hope we don't have to come down to that.

Sandra Ung

But thank you for the commitment.

Sandra Ung

With your understanding that you can't please everyone, would you agree it's fair, it isn't fair, to disregard the concerns of the affected communities as they perceive the impacts of new development coming into their neighborhood,

Sandra Ung

particularly with BSA approvals, because that would invariably mean that development would not be complying with existing zoning rules.

John Mangin

Thank you, Chair.

John Mangin

Yes, I mean, I believe that local voices are paramount when it comes to land use decisions.

John Mangin

That doesn't mean that they're always decisive, but I do hold them as paramount.