Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Minority Leader Carr Q&A: Mangin on charter revision and development timeline

New York City Council · Sep 1, 2026 · starts 2:44:12 · 1 min 25 sec

Carr questions why the charter revision focused on the council's 50-day ULURP role when the full development process averages 3.4 years. Mangin says the charter efforts were part of a range of streamlining efforts including pre-certification processes at DCP.

David M. Carr

You know, you were being very modest earlier about the scope of the changes of the charter revisions that were accomplished by the last Charter Revision Commission.

David M. Carr

There's been a recent analysis by Rebney that it takes about 3.4 years for a single new residential building in the city.

David M. Carr

It's an average of more than four, I think, in Manhattan.

David M. Carr

And given that the council's role in ULERP that has been removed was, you know, at most 50 days, why wasn't there more focus in the revision commission on

David M. Carr

the rest of the process, which clearly takes much longer, rather than on the council's role, which is a very small space in time when you consider the entire development.

John Mangin

Thank you for that question, Leader.

John Mangin

I would say the charter efforts were part of a range of similar efforts to address those issues.

John Mangin

I can say at City Planning, for instance, that we've been engaged in a pretty deep effort to try to streamline pre-certification processes for certain applications because, as you point out, it's not...

John Mangin

Just council, it's not just environmental review, it's not just DOB,

John Mangin

you know, these are all parts of a single process, all of which should be examined in order to make sure that they're serving the policy goals that we as a city are headed toward.