Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Agency Testimony

Commissioner Martin details concerns with Intro 181 on shower hoses

New York City Council · Sep 2, 2026 · starts 1:05:59 · 1 min 10 sec

Martin explains concerns that Intro 181 would trigger shower hose requirements for sporadic cases with no heightened risk, and worries about plumbing type challenges and costs being passed to tenants. He offers to discuss targeting improvements.

Commissioner Martin

We have concerns with introduction.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

181, 999, and 1006.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

Introduction 181 would require owners of buildings where one resident has Legionnaire's disease to provide shower hoses and information to tenants within 24 hours of that person being diagnosed.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

There are hundreds of cases of Legionnaire's disease in New York City each year.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

And our case investigators review every single one.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

A pattern of cases grouped in space and time suggests that Legionella bacteria may be growing in the built environment, and we can act to cut it off.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

Most of the time, our investigators do not observe a pattern, and the cases are sporadic.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

We would not have evidence that there is any heightened Legionnaires disease risk for tenants and that a shower hose would serve to reduce their risk.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

We're also concerned that the bill does not consider the types of plumbing within the building, which could create challenges, potentially including additional expense to utilizing a hose.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

We want to be sure that the expense associated with the bill would not be passed on to tenants.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

We have suggestions for the ways the bill can better target the concerns and look forward to discussing with council.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.