Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Agency Testimony

Commissioner Martin opposes Intro 999 pop-up testing sites

New York City Council · Sep 2, 2026 · starts 1:07:09 · 49 sec

Martin argues Legionnaires is not COVID and pop-up testing sites have no clinical or public health benefit, could lead to inappropriate care, and that symptomatic individuals should see doctors in healthcare settings rather than wait for test results.

Commissioner Martin

Introduction 999 would establish Legionnaire's disease testing sites.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

Legionnaire's disease is not COVID.

Commissioner Martin

There's no clinical or public health benefit to pop-up testing sites.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

And in fact, it could lead to inappropriate care.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

Pop-up clinics are not appropriate for screening and testing for Legionnaire's disease, which requires symptom screening, triage,

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

physical exam, diagnostic testing as necessary.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

And that could include other things like chest x-rays and blood tests.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

Furthermore, there is no public health benefit to testing people with no symptoms, as Legionnaire's disease is not transmitted person to person.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

For those with signs and symptoms, they should be tested and cared for by a doctor in a healthcare setting.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.

Commissioner Martin

They should not be waiting for test results to get care and possible treatment.

Member of the Public - Valerie Mason

We were overwhelmed with inquiries about whether people should be able to go to the Upper East Side.