Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Council Member Ariola on mayor's absence and DOH building compliance

New York City Council · Sep 2, 2026 · starts 2:30:12 · 4 min

Council Member Ariola criticizes the mayor's absence and asks whether two Harlem DOH buildings are fully staffed with stationary engineers and in compliance with fire and building codes for cooling tower maintenance. Martin says they will follow up on specifics.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you, Councilmember.

Lynn C. Schulman

Is that right?

Lynn C. Schulman

Okay.

Lynn C. Schulman

Councilmember Areola.

Joann Ariola

Thank you, Chair.

Joann Ariola

Thank you, Speaker.

Joann Ariola

You know, earlier today, I was listening to the testimony of Valerie Massim from Community Board 8, and she testified that Mayor Mamdani did not visit the area

Joann Ariola

where 94 people became sick with Legionnaire's disease and 11 died of the same disease.

Joann Ariola

I sat there, I listened, and I could not believe the horror in her voice that the mayor's absence was so obvious during a life-threatening, life-taking crisis

Joann Ariola

in his city, and yet he did not show up.

Joann Ariola

Why didn't he show up?

Joann Ariola

He certainly was available because he was performing for the cameras to say that he was going to arrest Bibi Netanyahu when he came here to New York City, which turned out to be false.

Joann Ariola

So he wasted his time and the people of this city's residents'time.

Joann Ariola

By not giving them the personal attention they deserved for this crisis.

Joann Ariola

And thankfully, the speaker

Joann Ariola

this chair, this committee, and this body would not do the same.

Joann Ariola

Question.

Joann Ariola

Are both the new DOH building at 40 West 137th Street and 2238 5th Avenue, both located in Harlem,

Joann Ariola

fully staffed and in compliance with the New York City Fire Code and the building code with stationary engineers that are responsible for the operations and maintenance and water treatment of the cooling towers and air conditioning systems?

Unidentified speaker

Let me get to your second question in a second, but first let me start with a response to the initial statement.

Unidentified speaker

The mayor has been and was from the beginning involved in this cluster.

Unidentified speaker

We spoke every single day during this cluster.

Joann Ariola

Okay, I don't really want to use up time on this, but he wasn't present.

Joann Ariola

And that's where he should have been, not trying to fool the residents of New York City thinking that he could have Bibi Netanyahu arrested when there were people dying in this city.

Joann Ariola

That's where he should have been.

Joann Ariola

So please answer the question.

Unidentified speaker

The question was these two specific buildings and the inspection history.

Joann Ariola

Are they fully staffed in compliance with the New York City Fire Code and Building Code with stationary engineers that are responsible for operations and maintenance and water treatment of the cooling system, towers, and air conditioning systems?

Unidentified speaker

We're going to get back to you on the details on those two specific buildings, Councilmember.

Joann Ariola

Okay, so do you know that the stationary engineers who operate these

Joann Ariola

Machines are responsible for checking the water treatment logs and testing required by the DOH is part of their job as their civil service description provides.

Joann Ariola

Are you aware of that?

Unidentified speaker

The buildings that you're describing, I'm not sure which buildings you're describing.

Unidentified speaker

We're going to get back to them in details.

Unidentified speaker

If they have towers.

Joann Ariola

So you know how you could answer that?

Joann Ariola

One more moment?

Joann Ariola

Yeah.

Joann Ariola

Is if Assistant Commissioner John Beattie was here to testify, because he's in charge of those operations, and he's in charge of that maintenance of those buildings.

Joann Ariola

And why isn't he here to answer questions like that?

Joann Ariola

Because those are very important questions to ask moving forward to make sure that Legionnaire's disease does not have additional outbreaks.

Joann Ariola

These answers should be able to be given to us today.

Joann Ariola

But again, the mayor's office has failed to have the proper people at the dais answering questions.

Unidentified speaker

Councilmember, we have the right people here able to answer your questions.

Unidentified speaker

We will get back to you on the details of those two specific buildings.

Joann Ariola

These questions should be able to be answered now, and I thank you for the extra time.

Lynn C. Schulman

Okay, thank you.