Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Council Member Aldebol on water ecologist hiring challenges and timelines

New York City Council · Sep 2, 2026 · starts 2:25:15 · 4 min 57 sec

Council Member Aldebol questions when the 23 new positions were filled, challenges in hiring, and whether recruitment is effective. Martin explains the specialized civil service requirements and Schiff notes the difficulty finding qualified candidates with specific science credentials.

Lynn C. Schulman

Thank you, Council Member.

Lynn C. Schulman

Council Member Aldebar.

Shirley Aldebol

Thank you, Chair and Speaker Menon and Commissioner for being here today.

Shirley Aldebol

So you said you had 23 new positions funded November of 2025.

Shirley Aldebol

When were the majority of those positions filled?

Shirley Aldebol

You said the positions are filled today, but how long did it take you to actually fill those positions?

Commissioner Martin

Yep, the majority of those positions were filled before this cluster started.

Commissioner Martin

We can get you the exact dates of those over the course of the several months prior to the close.

Shirley Aldebol

And you still have six positions that remain to be filled in this particular job title, the water ecologist title?

Commissioner Martin

That's right.

Shirley Aldebol

And what have been the challenges in hiring for those titles?

Commissioner Martin

I would say the most important challenge is the fact that these are highly specialized, highly skilled positions.

Commissioner Martin

The requirements are that these folks have to have, for instance, a master's degree or potentially a BA with 24 credits plus related experience.

Commissioner Martin

So these are highly skilled, highly specialized positions.

Commissioner Martin

So it's not just about finding any person for these slots.

Commissioner Martin

We have to find the right person for these slots.

Shirley Aldebol

Is it possible that...

Shirley Aldebol

folks could be hired in these positions and receive additional training.

Shirley Aldebol

To get them certified?

Shirley Aldebol

Does the Department of Health provide colleges, universities with

Shirley Aldebol

these specific criteria for these jobs.

Virginia Maloney

So of course we do provide training once the staff start to be able to do the cooling tower inspections, but I think you're asking something different.

Virginia Maloney

You're asking about looking to colleges to

Virginia Maloney

to qualify people to be able to apply for these jobs.

Virginia Maloney

And it's such an important point that we need more people going into the sciences to be able to do these jobs.

Virginia Maloney

But as the commissioner said, these are the civil service requirements, either to have a master's degree in very specific areas of the sciences or a BA in those same areas with prior work experience.

Virginia Maloney

So that is the challenge.

Virginia Maloney

I will say we would welcome your help in getting the word out that we are recruiting.

Virginia Maloney

It is a great job.

Virginia Maloney

We have a mission-driven, wonderful team, and we have some more positions to fill.

Shirley Aldebol

Yeah, not so easy because I don't know too many water ecologists kind of running around my neighborhood who are looking for this job.

Shirley Aldebol

But I think...

Shirley Aldebol

I think it requires a discussion about the qualifications and how, you know, is the recruitment for these positions effective enough?

Shirley Aldebol

Because just putting something in LinkedIn is not going to get you there, right?

Shirley Aldebol

I think the other question that I have, if I may, Chair, what other positions are critical to the management of Legionella?

Shirley Aldebol

And are you seeking to expand those job positions?

Shirley Aldebol

And are there vacancies in those positions currently?

Commissioner Martin

Yeah, I'll speak to the first, which is a new addition from last year, and then I'll hand it to Deputy Commissioner Dr.

Commissioner Martin

Howard to talk a little bit about the laboratory work.

Commissioner Martin

But the community health workers that we were able to deploy as part of this cluster were, from my perspective, very critical.

Commissioner Martin

We had these community health workers out there within 48 hours on the Upper East Side engaging with residents, with individuals.

Commissioner Martin

I was out there with them doing some of the canvassing and talking to residents.

Commissioner Martin

So that was critical when it comes to managing these clusters.

Commissioner Martin

Let me hand it to Dr.

Commissioner Martin

Howard.

Dr. Andrea Howard

So we have epidemiologists that do the surveillance for Legionnaire's disease as well as other diseases and also do the case investigations.

Dr. Andrea Howard

And then on the laboratory side, we have a wide range of staff that do the actual testing.

Dr. Howard

testing of the cooling tower samples, which includes the PCR testing and the culture testing, and then the whole genome sequencing and analysis.