Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Speaker Menin on water ecologist vacancies before outbreak

New York City Council · Sep 2, 2026 · starts 1:22:57 · 1 min 22 sec

Menin presses why 21 of 56 authorized water ecologist positions were unfilled heading into summer. Martin clarifies 50 of 56 are now filled with 6 open, and says the majority were filled before the cluster. Menin disputes this based on her data.

Julie Menin

In addition, during the outbreak, only 35 of 56 authorized water ecologist positions were staffed.

Julie Menin

Heading into the summer months.

Julie Menin

So there were 21 authorized positions that the department never staffed with active inspectors.

Commissioner Martin

Let me clarify the record.

Commissioner Martin

on that speaker.

Commissioner Martin

There are 56 total budgeted positions for the water ecologists.

Commissioner Martin

50 of those positions either have people who are on the ground, on the roofs, I was with some of them just a couple weeks ago doing our water inspections, or going through the onboarding process.

Commissioner Martin

You are right.

Commissioner Martin

There are folks who we have not recruited, we have not hired.

Commissioner Martin

We have six open positions, and we are trying to make sure we get the right people for each of those roles.

Commissioner Martin

Those are highly specialized roles.

Commissioner Martin

But the vast majority of these, even the new positions that we got, were filled and had folks either on the ground or on board.

Julie Menin

Right, but not before the outbreak occurred.

Julie Menin

The point is that...

Julie Menin

Why between January and May, heading into the summer months, did the department leave 21 authorized positions of active inspectors open?

Julie Menin

That's the point.

Julie Menin

Very good that now it's being filled, but our point is that had the department have filled these vacant positions, we would probably not be in this situation that we're in right now.

Julie Menin

So that's what I'm trying to get to.

Julie Menin

If we could move on.