Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Speaker Menin on 25% non-compliance and lack of pre-summer enforcement

New York City Council · Sep 2, 2026 · starts 1:24:18 · 1 min 59 sec

Menin asks why few violations were issued in May and June if 25% of buildings were non-compliant with the new law. Martin says compliance was 74% in the cluster region and 77% citywide, and transparency measures pushed it to 97%.

Julie Menin

How many buildings were non-compliant with Chair Shulman's 2025 law when it went into effect in May and June?

Julie Menin

Our understanding of the data, please correct us if we're incorrect, is that 25% of buildings were not in compliance.

Julie Menin

So why were there so few violations issued in May and June if there were 25% non-compliant buildings?

Commissioner Martin

Across the city, citywide compliance with the new law was 77%.

Commissioner Martin

That was about eight weeks after the new law had gone into effect.

Commissioner Martin

Within the region, within the cluster region, compliance was 74%.

Commissioner Martin

While the cluster carried on, as you know, we decided to take the most transparent step we've ever done as part of these clusters, and we released the names of the PCR-positive buildings.

Commissioner Martin

And by the end of this cluster, through that process, 97% of those towers that we inspected were compliant.

Commissioner Martin

And that's why the lesson that we learned from this process is that this transparency is a critical feature, critical part of the work to increase compliance on this brand new law.

Commissioner Martin

And that's why one of our measures that we announced just yesterday is to further increase the transparency by

Commissioner Martin

allowing residents to use this new tool where they can put their address in and get a map to see what the compliance history is of the towers in their neighborhood.

Julie Menin

And that's, I guess, and I'm sure Chair Shulman will talk about that, but that is why we wanted, coming into the summer months, the proactive enforcement.

Julie Menin

Again, this is sort of one of the themes that's coming out in this hearing.

Julie Menin

We need far more proactive enforcement.

Julie Menin

If there were 25% noncompliant buildings, there should have been far more active enforcement heading into the summer months.

Julie Menin

I have two more questions.

Julie Menin

I have many more questions, but then I'm going to go.

Julie Menin

I pass it on to Chair Shulman.