Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Thomas-Henry questions per-unit city capital cost and resale equity stipulations

New York City Council · Sep 8, 2026 · starts 0:21:27 · 2 min 30 sec

Thomas-Henry asks about the actual per-unit cost; Adler reports approximately $800,000 per unit in city capital, similar to the 171st Street cluster. Thomas-Henry then asks about resale stipulations; Adler and Tompkins explain the flip tax structure, with insider flip tax starting at 90-95% and decreasing to 10%, while new purchasers face a flat 10% flip tax.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

And I noticed you said HPD City Capital makes up the bulk of the project source at roughly $500,000 to $700,000.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Have you actually penciled out what the actual cost would be per unit?

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

Because of, so we're currently working on reconciliation with it, and we are going through a certain internal process with HPD's, basically the wing of HPD that does

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

the construction and the monitoring and cost and design review to make sure that these numbers are clean.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

Because of the...

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

Unusually large number of insider units in this project.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

Usually it's much lower, so you can sell vacant units for more and make up a bulk of that money.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

The city capital money on this project is around $800,000.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

That is similar to the...

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

Total?

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

Yeah.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

For the entire project?

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

$800,000 per unit.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Per unit.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Oh, okay.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

That is similar to the 171st Street cluster.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

Is that the name of Shams Project?

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

That recently came through City Council.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

And then my last question is for you to show the equity.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Are there any stipulations for either the existing tenants or the new tenants that come in when and how they can sell?

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

Yes, that goes into our regulatory agreement under the.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

We'll be back.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

We basically call it a flip tax to ensure that basically the longer that you stay in the unit, the more profit you can take when you resell it.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

If we can go back a few slides until we get to that.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

I can just tell you when to stop.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

Yep, there we go.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

Oh, one more forward.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

There we go.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

So this is the basic outline of what that looks like.

Member of the Public - Daniel Tompkins

But they can sell it anytime.

Member of the Public - Daniel Tompkins

It's just the amount of time increases the profits they would realize and the equity they would realize from resale.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Got it.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

And it would be the same for both the existing tenants that are moving back and the new tenants?

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

Correct.

Member of the Public - Daniel Tompkins

No.

Member of the Public - Daniel Tompkins

Sorry, no.

Member of the Public - Daniel Tompkins

The flip tax for new purchasers is 10% in perpetuity.

Member of the Public - Daniel Tompkins

The flip tax for insider tenants who become homeowners starts at, I think, 90%.

Member of the Public - Daniel Tompkins

Is that what it is?

Member of the Public - Daniel Tompkins

Or 95% and then slowly decreases until it reaches that 10%.

Member of the Public - Emily Adler

Gotcha.

Shanel Thomas-Henry

Thank you.