Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Stephanie Thomas (3435 Giles Place tenant) on building conditions under Park Cash Realty

New York City Council · Sep 9, 2026 · starts 4:27:37 · 2 min 28 sec

Thomas describes years of no heat, broken elevators, water leaks, stolen packages, roaches and mice at her building, and recounts being told by the owner's son to 'move' if unsatisfied. She urges passage of COPA and the Safer Homes Act.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

My name is Stephanie Thomas.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

I'm a proud member of R Bronx and a tenant of 3435 Giles Place, Bronx, New York.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Documentation supports this testimony describing absolute mismanagement by Park Cash Realty of the previous mentioned property.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

The following allegations reiterate the maladministration of the aforementioned property.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

These examples will emphasize the dire need to pass COPA and the Safer Homes Act.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

I've resided at this property since October 2015 and strongly believe these initiatives will address the deterioration of our building and community.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Some of these are no heat during the winter months, elevator continuously inoperable and unsafe to use when working.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Elevator engineer is usually called on average of five times per week.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Water leaks in most apartments, hallways, etc., especially during rainstorms.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Faulty patchwork, so problems recur.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Water leaks in the lobby area.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Apartments on the seventh floor experience severe water damage due to faulty roof repair.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Mailroom.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

The mailroom.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Room is unsecured.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Requests for mailboxes for packages are ignored.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Packages are continuously stolen.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

Roaches and mice are throughout the building.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

What's most infuriating is the lack of concern by the owner and his sons in regards to these allegations.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

For example, I called about the inoperable elevator in 2016 and was told,

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

If I was unsatisfied with the situation, I could move.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

This is how Park Cash Realty feels about their tenants.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

The nonchalant attitude about the welfare of tenants depicts the worst kind of apartment ownership in our city.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

COPA and the Safer Homes Act will give legal authority over landlords who neglect their contractual responsibilities and fail to keep their properties safe.

Member of the Public - Stephanie Thomas

It's time tenants stand up for their rights.

Unidentified speaker

We need legal support and assistance from our city officials.

Unidentified speaker

Thank you.