Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Maloney questions responsibility for metrics, testing, and public communication

New York City Council · Sep 9, 2026 · starts 2:08:52 · 2 min 2 sec

Maloney asks who is responsible for tracking metrics and testing (both OTI and Motorola), who manages the vendor (OTI), and who communicates to the public during outages. Gelobter says NYSEM sends messages but the criteria and process for when they're notified need to be determined. Maloney asks who let NYSEM know and when—they became aware at 9:30 a.m. with 45 minutes of known impact.

Virginia Maloney

And

Virginia Maloney

Who is responsible for tracking those metrics and conducting testing?

Virginia Maloney

Is it OTI or Motorola?

Lisa Gelobter

Both.

Virginia Maloney

And who's responsible for managing the vendor?

Lisa Gelobter

That would be OTI.

Virginia Maloney

And we touched on this, but who's responsible for communicating to the public when there's an issue or an outage?

Lisa Gelobter

So I think that is one of the things in terms of the protocols and policies that we have to determine more comprehensively going forward.

Lisa Gelobter

Who makes those calls?

Lisa Gelobter

NISM is the one who sends out the messages.

Lisa Gelobter

And then how do they get notified?

Lisa Gelobter

And based on what criteria is that decision made?

Virginia Maloney

So just one last question is if NISM is responsible for communicating to the public currently, at least, who communicated with NISM and when were they made aware?

Virginia Maloney

In order to communicate it more broadly.

Lisa Gelobter

Yes.

Lisa Gelobter

Thank you for the question.

Lisa Gelobter

In this case, we became aware that there was an issue with New Yorkers calling 911 at about 9.30 in the morning.

Lisa Gelobter

It was remediated by about 10.19 in the morning.

Lisa Gelobter

So it was about a 45-minute period where we knew that New Yorkers were being impacted.

Lisa Gelobter

About 70% of the calls were still being answered.

Lisa Gelobter

So during that time frame, those 45 minutes, our main focus was on diagnosing the issue so that we could remediate it.

Lisa Gelobter

So the first 20 minutes or so,

Lisa Gelobter

of that was trying to diagnose the source of the issue, and then the 25 minutes remaining were about rerouting calls to the systems that we knew were functioning.

Virginia Maloney

And who is responsible for letting NYSEM know when there was an outage?

Lisa Gelobter

I think that is something that we need to be more specific about going forward, and that will be part of our analysis.

Virginia Maloney

And looking forward to the root cause analysis.

Virginia Maloney

Thank you, Chair.

Lisa Gelobter

Thank you.

Lisa Gelobter

Here's Council Member Riley.