Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Public testimony: Rafael Moure-Punnett (CB6) explains board's no vote on Phipps track record

New York City Council · Sep 9, 2026 · starts 3:26:12 · 2 min 1 sec

Rafael Moure-Punnett, district manager for Bronx Community Board 6, explains the board voted no because Phipps can build 300 units as-of-right without rezoning. He argues the council should only reward responsible developers with discretionary rezoning, citing federal class action lawsuits and high housing code violations at Phipps properties.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

Thank you, council members, for holding this hearing.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

My name is Rafael Mori-Pinette.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

I'm the district manager for Bronx Community Board 6.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

The community board voted no on the sojourner Mavis pre-zoning, and I wanted to clarify some of the points made by the board in our letter to the committee.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

Community Board 6, this area is an area where a lot of as-of-right development happens.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

There are regularly...

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

Tall buildings built out of houses that are combined in multiple lots into one new building.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

As a result, Community Board 6 has a very active development market, and we are doing more than our fair share of new housing construction.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

for the city.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

This rezoning, this discretionary rezoning before the council is not going to make or break the real estate market in our district.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

And we have encouraged the council to vote no on this because we know that FIPS can still build 300 units on this law without a rezoning.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

And we believe that the city council should really only reward responsible developers with rezoning.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

A developer that doesn't have a good track record in a neighborhood is not a good candidate for discretionary rezoning.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

The board hears from, on a regular basis,

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

many FIPS tenants, including a tenant last night at our Housing and Land Use Committee, with serious concerns about FIPS's management practices, some of which have been brought up today.

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

And, you know, FIPS tenants organized and a federal class action lawsuit was filed against FIPS, alleging these

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

management practices that cause severe harm to the tenants, whether they're repairs, rent recertification, or things of that nature, the buildings in this rezoning area are

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

referred to in our letter as having high housing code violations and serious

Member of the Public - Rafael Moure-Punnett

problems for the tenants in that area.