Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Krishnan and Dinowitz close DOE questioning with follow-up items and concerns

New York City Council · Sep 15, 2026 · starts 2:33:02 · 3 min 27 sec

Krishnan adds the assessment screen time loophole to the follow-up list. Dinowitz summarizes remaining concerns about teacher PD, research rubrics, data privacy audits, and calls for the best policy in the country rooted in research and transparency. Chancellor Samuels thanks the committees.

Shekar Krishnan

Thank you.

Shekar Krishnan

I just wanted to just add one thing to the list we said before of things to follow up on.

Shekar Krishnan

I think Fiancema Murano had said a really good question, too, about for now, I think this is an immediate step you all could take, too.

Shekar Krishnan

How do you balance out in the screen time policy you all have in place, 30 or 45 minutes allowed?

Shekar Krishnan

Online assessments are exempted from that, but obviously that's also a loophole that could be a huge carve out if they're online assessments and they're screen time.

Shekar Krishnan

And so I would ask that you all look at ways to issue instructions to the school too, that that loophole shouldn't become something in addition to the screen time allowance right now too.

Unidentified speaker

Thank you.

Unidentified speaker

Thank you.

Unidentified speaker

Okay.

Unidentified speaker

I also, I know, Chair Krishna, I want to thank you.

Unidentified speaker

I mean, there's significantly more to discuss, obviously.

Unidentified speaker

I think it's clear that both there have been changes to policy made, that you're listening, but that there's also a lot more to do.

Unidentified speaker

Families remain concerned.

Unidentified speaker

Teachers remain concerned with the amount of screens in the school.

Unidentified speaker

I still remain concerned about the PD.

Unidentified speaker

That teachers are going to get, like what the policy actually looks like.

Unidentified speaker

I still remain concerned about the research, the rubric that you're using for each of these technology companies, what that actually looks like.

Unidentified speaker

I remain concerned about the data privacy audits, whether any have been done, and with that being shared with the public.

Unidentified speaker

And so it's clear that the ideas for moving forward and keeping our kids safer there, and what we're really eager to do is make sure that we have

Unidentified speaker

the best policy in the country, rooted in research, rooted in transparency,

Unidentified speaker

rooted in evidence, and that we are all holding each other accountable to make sure our kids are getting the best education possible, that our kids are protected as they use these screens,

Unidentified speaker

and if necessary, go back.

Unidentified speaker

And determine, you know what, let's figure out a way to ban the gamified apps.

Unidentified speaker

You know, let's work together to switch back to get this.

Unidentified speaker

to switch us back to handwritten state assessments.

Unidentified speaker

And that'll open up an entire world of better education, get rid of the excuse so many teachers feel they need to put screens in our kids'hands.

Unidentified speaker

But again, I wanna, we will follow up with a number of the elements that we didn't get answers to today, but I do wanna thank you for coming, for answering the questions, and I look forward to a continued conversation because this is by no means

Unidentified speaker

over and I encourage you to stay to hear some of the students testify and some of the community members testify as well.

Chancellor Samuels

Thank you so much again.

Chancellor Samuels

You know, it's hard to believe we announced the policy 13 days ago.

Chancellor Samuels

We're in the fourth instructional day of school.

Chancellor Samuels

We have much to learn.

Chancellor Samuels

I want to thank you so much for the opportunity today to have this conversation so publicly.

Chancellor Samuels

I know that a lot of the conversation today helped clarify some of the policy and raised really great feedback that we look forward to exploring with you throughout the school year.

Chancellor Samuels

And we can't wait to collect more stories about how implementation is going and bring those back to you.

Chancellor Samuels

So thank you today for the time.

Unidentified speaker

Thank you.