Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Krishnan questions Chromebooks going home with K-2 students

New York City Council · Sep 15, 2026 · starts 0:51:58 · 1 min 46 sec

Krishnan raises concerns about K-2 students bringing Chromebooks home, opening up screen time negotiations at home. Giunta acknowledges limited need for daily device use at home but notes remote learning days require device readiness.

Shekar Krishnan

Okay.

Shekar Krishnan

Now, I know there's a difference between K through 2 and 3 to 5.

Shekar Krishnan

Focusing on K through 2 for a minute, no one-to-one devices are allowed.

Shekar Krishnan

The policy was silent, though, on are students permitted to bring their Chromebooks home with them, which raises a number of issues.

Shekar Krishnan

One, just they're very little, carrying those laptops back and forth every day.

Shekar Krishnan

But also, once that's introduced at home, it opens a new door and a new set of negotiations over whether to use those laptops, whether to play on them, under the guise of...

Shekar Krishnan

eyes of learning, which our creative kindergartners through second graders are always citing as well.

Shekar Krishnan

So what is the DOE's policy for K through 2?

Shekar Krishnan

If there's no one-to-one learning, are Chromebooks permitted to come home with students?

Danielle Giunta

We would imagine that, of course, children should not need their computers on a daily, their individual Chromebooks on a daily basis at all.

Danielle Giunta

We also want our kids to know, like, we will have a remote day.

Danielle Giunta

We might have a pivots remote, whether it's weather or some other event.

Danielle Giunta

We're also planning for a remote day on election day.

Danielle Giunta

So we do want to leverage opportunities for students to be able to understand how to access their Google Classrooms, how to access homework that might be posted digitally.

Danielle Giunta

And we also know that in our schools, there might be an opportunity not for one-to-one device, but, you know,

Danielle Giunta

we have our digital library where kids might be pulling up, a teacher might pull up a book and a kid can read along with the story.

Danielle Giunta

But I think we'll see limited back and forth of our littlest carrying our laptops every day.