Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Sanchez questions Anderson on additional city-owned land for composting beyond Rikers

New York City Council · Sep 15, 2026 · starts 0:45:26 · 1 min 54 sec

Sanchez asks about other islands or city-owned land for composting. Anderson says most other islands have environmental protections or federal ownership restrictions, and DSNY is also exploring regional options outside NYC with private industry.

Justin E. Sanchez

Speaking of composting, given that you mentioned Rikers and the opportunity for composting there, I wanted to know, are there any other islands

Justin E. Sanchez

or city-owned land that you or the department are looking at for potential spots for composting as well?

Gregory Anderson

We're certainly always looking for potential locations for new compost facilities.

Gregory Anderson

I think the challenge with a lot of the rest of New York City is that we are competing against other potential uses for city-owned property or even for privately owned property.

Gregory Anderson

And in many cases, there are better uses.

Gregory Anderson

Housing, for example, is a better use for much of the city's land than compost facilities.

Gregory Anderson

So I think that's why we've really zeroed in on Rikers Island, because it's not really appropriate for residential development.

Gregory Anderson

It's a very large place.

Gregory Anderson

It's physically separated from other neighborhoods.

Gregory Anderson

And so it's sort of ripe for that kind of industrial use.

Gregory Anderson

We're also always...

Gregory Anderson

Looking at this as a regional issue, because there is a substantial amount of property outside of New York City that may be a better use for or location for a compost facility.

Gregory Anderson

So we're always in conversations with the private industry around potential development of new sites that could take New York City material.

Justin E. Sanchez

Is there any...

Justin E. Sanchez

like discussion about like some of the smaller islands and just turning into a compost island, like a brother, a brother island or, you know, any of those smaller places that, you know, are not.

Gregory Anderson

Many of the other islands are either protected as either, you know, environmental,

Gregory Anderson

like conservation habitats or their property of the federal government or there are other kinds of restrictions on their use.

Gregory Anderson

And so there's complications with everything.

Gregory Anderson

But if you have ideas, we're certainly happy to look at them.

Justin E. Sanchez

Great.