Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

CM Ariola on 911 audit system and 580 officer budget cut

New York City Council · Sep 16, 2026 · starts 0:52:24 · 2 min 12 sec

Ariola asks about 911 call-to-report audits and the 580 officer budget cut. Gerber describes ICAT audits comparing 911 calls to complaint reports, and says while more officers are always preferable, NYPD is having tremendous success with current staffing.

Joann Ariola

So because we're on crime data and statistics and follow-up, does the NYPD keep a record of 911 calls for crimes being reported compared to the amount of reports that are actually being taken by the officers?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

Right, so we actually do audits on this.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

So we have, as part of our auditing system, and we can talk more about that, but one of the audits that we do...

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

Is an ICAT audit.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

So

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

What we will do is, and we do this both at the command level in terms of self-inspections, and then separately from the crime audit team, we'll do ICAT audits, where we take 911 calls,

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

Right?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

And radio runs.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

And we have a sampling of how we do it.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

And then we check.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

Right?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

And we say, okay, there was a call for burglary in progress.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

Right?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

A robbery in progress.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

Okay, now we're going to check.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

One, was a complaint taken?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

And two, if it was taken, was it taken properly?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

So we do have a whole auditing process in place to address this issue.

Joann Ariola

Right.

Joann Ariola

May I ask just a little lead time?

Joann Ariola

Thanks.

Joann Ariola

So in this year's budget, Mayor Momdani cut 580 police officers from the budget.

Joann Ariola

Do you have any idea where those police officers might have been assigned if they had been budgeted?

Joann Ariola

And do you believe those additional officers, specifically the ones that may have been assigned to the Bronx, would have had a beneficial impact on crime stats in that borough?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

So I certainly can't speak to where sort of hypothetically officers would have been assigned.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

And, you know, look, obviously, if we didn't have budgetary restrictions, like in a vacuum, as between more police officers and fewer police officers, of course we're always going to want more.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

But, but.

Joann Ariola

It makes sense that if we had those extra 580 cops, we would.

Joann Ariola

have 580 cops more on the street and less crime.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

But I do want to say that we understand, obviously, that we have budgetary constraints.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

And we feel like with the cops that we have, we're having a tremendous amount of success in fighting crime.