Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

CM Ariola on crime reporting refusals and Washington Square Park video

New York City Council · Sep 16, 2026 · starts 0:49:38 · 2 min 46 sec

Ariola raises videos of officers refusing to take crime reports, including a Washington Square Park incident. Gerber calls the video unacceptable, confirms IAB investigation, and says most officers take reports properly but misconduct is disciplined severely under Commissioner Tisch.

Joann Ariola

Do you know how many additional New Yorkers were assaulted this year by defendants who had already been arrested for another violent offense while a previous case of theirs was still pending?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

So we will pull that for you.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

I don't think we have it here, but that is data that we have and we can provide.

Joann Ariola

Okay.

Joann Ariola

So I just want to talk now about reporting of crimes.

Joann Ariola

We've all seen the videos circulating online most recently from officers in Washington Square Park and heard that several reports from Times Square or elsewhere in the city of officers either refusing to take a report or...

Joann Ariola

Dissuading individuals from filing reports.

Joann Ariola

Do you ever receive complaints from the public about officers refusing to take a report or misclassifying what they say?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

Yeah, so first of all, I just want to say that with that video, I'm familiar with the video, totally unacceptable.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

It is under investigation by IAB, right?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

We have that case.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

It's under investigation.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

And yes, this is not a new issue, right?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

Most officers do this the right way.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

I want to say it's actually very important, right?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

Most cops are taking crime reports.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

They're there to help victims.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

They're trying to achieve justice for them.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

You're going to have a small number of officers who don't do this the right way, right?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

There are times when that's negligence.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

lack of training, a training issue, and there are times when it's misconduct.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

And I want to be very clear that when we have misconduct, particularly under Commissioner Tisch, these matters are investigated rigorously and the disciplinary consequences can be severe.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

I also, if I may, I just want to...

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

There are many reasons why it's so problematic, right?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

The obvious reason is just terribly wrong, right?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

Someone experienced a crime, they're trying to report it, and officers not taking their complaint, and in that case, apparently almost seeming to mock it.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

That's just wrong, full stop.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

It undermines credibility of the public, which is a terrible thing.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

There's also another issue, which is the department, like everything we've been talking about, it runs, the department runs on crime data, right?

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

And we need good data for deployment, for resource allocation, for follow-up.

Joann Ariola

Okay, so I'm going to stop you there because I have a couple more questions.