Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

PA Williams on response time data and crime data revision updates

New York City Council · Sep 16, 2026 · starts 0:46:07 · 2 min 1 sec

Williams asks whether NYPD reports when complainants are gone upon police arrival and whether crime data is updated after audits. Gerber says they'll try to pull data on complainant absence and confirms crime numbers are always updated with latest classifications.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

If I could just ask one more question.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

I appreciate that.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

I had one question.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

I know that response times have become delayed.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

I experienced it myself.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

I also sometimes do that delay.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

Complaintants are gone when law enforcement comes.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

I just want to know if we have any numbers on times that police may have arrived and the complaint wasn't there because that wouldn't show up.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

And also, in my report, I had a kind of question of when you give the numbers and there's an audit and there's a change, are those reports?

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

Changed after.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

Yeah, so sure.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

So first on the question about, you know, when you have a police response and the complainant is no longer there, you know, I just don't know if we have data on that.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

If we do, we will.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

provide it to you.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

We don't have it here.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

I have to look at sort of how we track that.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

But certainly if we can pull that data, we will provide it to your office.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

With regard to the crime data.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

So when a crime gets reclassified, the numbers get updated.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

Right, so what we're putting out, however we're putting out, whether it's Comstat 2.0 online, when we're providing

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

our monthly data to the state, which goes to the feds as well, when we're putting out the monthly press releases, whatever form we're doing this,

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

We're always using the latest numbers that we have, reflecting, as you know, changes that happen in crime classification in the normal course.

Member of the Public - Michael Gerber

And so, yes, the numbers do reflect that.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

Thank you.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

And thank you, Mr.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

Chair.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

New Yorkers don't feel as safe as we actually are, and we've got to figure out why that is, and we've got to make sure they can.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

Have faith in the numbers that are being pushed out there.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

So I really appreciate this hearing.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

Thank you.

Member of the Public - Jumaane Williams

Thank you.

Oswald J. Feliz

Thank you.

Oswald J. Feliz

Thank you so much, public advocate.

Oswald J. Feliz

I want to recognize Councilmember Murano.

Oswald J. Feliz

And next, we'll hear from Councilmember Ariola.