Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Teacher Eric Levine contrasts Regents school with consortium school

New York City Council · Sep 22, 2026 · starts 3:22:12 · 2 min 24 sec

Eric Levine, ninth grade social studies teacher and UFT chapter leader at Harvest Collegiate, says he hated his high-performing Regents high school. He now teaches in a consortium school where he can design rigorous, responsive classes that prioritize critical thinking and communication.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

My name is Eric Levine.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

I teach ninth grade social studies and lead the UFT chapter at Harvest Collegiate High School, a consortium school near Union Square.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

I became a teacher partly because I hated school.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

My parents put a great deal of value on education and moved me and my siblings just north of the city to Rockland County due to the reputation of the schools there.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

The high school I attended still hovers around the top 50 high schools in the state, and it was a miserable experience for me.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

At no point in those four years did I feel like my individuality was honored, that my interests were encouraged, or that I was learning what I would need for after graduation.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

As a teen, I became very interested in politics and current events.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

I wanted to get involved in the world around me, but my high school never offered an outlet for me to explore that.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

Instead, much of my time in high school was spent preparing for the New York State Regents.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

I often wondered if there wasn't a better way to educate students.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

So imagine my excitement when just weeks into my training as a teacher, I found that there were more than a dozen schools working together to do something better than the regions.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

Once I learned of the New York State Performance Standards Consortium, I never wanted to be or teach anywhere else.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

In the past 11 years, I've visited many of those schools and in every single instance have thought to myself, I wish I went to high school here.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

I taught in a traditional region school for a few years, waiting for the opportunity to work at a consortium school.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

My time was filled with prepackaged curriculum, rushed lessons in units, and a lack of rigorous work and deep thinking for my students.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

I did what I could, but at the end of the day, they needed to pass these tests.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

My school bragged about its high graduation and college acceptance rates, but never reflected on or commented on its low college retention rates.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

That model simply did not prepare students for the rigors and demands of what comes after high school.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

Consortium schools like mine

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

Better prepare students for what they will encounter after they leave.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

I have the freedom to design classes that are responsive to their interests and lives, that are deep and rigorous, and that are rooted in skills that will set them up for success after they graduate.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

There is no mad dash to cover 300 years of human history in nine months.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

Classes become living, breathing things that force students to think deeply about the world around them and make connections to their own lives.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

These classes prioritize critical thinking, reflection, and effective communication, as do the project-based assessments they lead to.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

They prepare students to be the global citizens that we hope they will be for the rest of their lives.

Member of the Public - Eric Levine

Working in a consortium school allows me and my colleagues to provide the kind of educational experience to hundreds of students that I wish I had been able to have had myself.

Eric Dinowitz

All right, fellow chapter leader, thank you.

Eric Dinowitz

You can begin whenever.

Eric Dinowitz

I don't know if you have any.

Eric Dinowitz

Oh, they're all done.

Eric Dinowitz

Okay.

Eric Dinowitz

I'd like to thank this panel for your testimony today.

Eric Dinowitz

Really appreciate it and appreciate your stories.