Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Vera Shengalia says performance-based assessment helped her daughter after immigration

New York City Council · Sep 22, 2026 · starts 3:19:21 · 2 min 51 sec

Vera Shengalia, parent of a consortium graduate and current Beacon student, says her daughter arrived from a third-world country and found her voice through performance-based assessments. Her daughter now studies at Cooper Union and was prepared to think, not just draw.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

Hi, my name is Vera Shingelia.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

I'm a mom of graduate of Urban Academy and a mom of a student who's in Beacon.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

So I know immigrants aren't the most popular group in America right now, but in New York, families like mine aren't the exception.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

We are the huge part of this city.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

We fled in a third-oriented country.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

When we arrived, my daughter, Vasilisa, was one of the many kids starting school here after their whole world had fallen apart.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

For a child that feels like landing on Mars.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

And I think the most important thing a school can do for that child is show her that not everything is gone.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

Adults still listen and questions are still welcome and her voice still belongs to her.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

A child in that state probably won't show her best thinking on a time test on one stressful morning.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

But give her time, a hard question, and a teacher who pays attention, and you'll see what she can really do.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

You cannot teach values through A, B, C, or D.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

They grow through practice.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

We're writing an essay for the fifth time, defending an idea out loud, fighting for your argument.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

That's what performance-based assessments ask of students.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

It isn't the easy option, and no one does it alone.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

It takes teachers, classmates, a community.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

Today, Vasilisa studies at Cooper Union.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

Entrance days gave her a few abstract prompts and four weeks to turn them into six original concepts.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

Drawing well wasn't enough.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

They wanted to see whether she could think.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

Her consortium school had prepared her for exactly that.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

You know that we parents are anxious people.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

We are always chasing the next goal.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

High school, college, good job, good salary.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

We rarely stop to ask why.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

Immigration made me stop.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

When you are running into the unknown with two kids and two suitcases, you remember very fast what matters.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

We want our children to be free, honest, and brave.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

As someone who fled an authoritarian country, I can tell you that people do not become free, honest, and courageous by learning to choose the correct box.

Eric Dinowitz

Thank you.

Eric Dinowitz

Thank you.

Eric Dinowitz

And I do want to address something.

Eric Dinowitz

I know that comment, the immigrants aren't the most popular group right now, is probably like a funny little side comment.

Eric Dinowitz

But I just want everyone watching to know that my office, the council, the Department of Education,

Eric Dinowitz

we do an incredible amount of work to celebrate and uplift our immigrant community because they are so loved.

Eric Dinowitz

It may not feel like that in the White House, but it's certainly that way here in New York City.

Eric Dinowitz

And I want everyone listening to know that.

Member of the Public - Vera Shengalia

Thank you so much from my family for that.

Eric Dinowitz

Yeah, thank you.