Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Hudson questions shopping letter renewal and six-month eligibility

New York City Council · Sep 22, 2026 · starts 1:16:41 · 4 min 5 sec

Hudson asks how shopping letters are renewed after six months and whether the six-month duration is necessary. Reed says letters are automatically renewed if eligibility continues; French says the six-month checkpoint reconfirms income and baseline eligibility.

Crystal Hudson

But with regards to the shopping letter, you said they are...

Crystal Hudson

Automatically renewed after six months?

Andrea Reed

They're automated.

Andrea Reed

Thank you for that.

Andrea Reed

They're automated, so it's an electronic process.

Andrea Reed

So it's issued.

Andrea Reed

It's available in Access HRA, so the client can go and see in their portal, the shopping letter, the case manager and or housing specialist provide a copy, and so that...

Andrea Reed

It's automatically renewed as long as they continue their eligibility.

Crystal Hudson

Do you know the average time it takes for someone to find an available unit?

Scott French

that we don't have that average time, just given there's a variety of different factors.

Scott French

I think we're going to look at the data that we do have to sort of see what might be something we could track as to like when the CityFAPS right package is submitted.

Scott French

That is probably the best sort of one of the markers that we have at the moment to look at.

Crystal Hudson

And so I guess I'm trying to figure out.

Crystal Hudson

How do you determine that six months is the most appropriate time for the eligibility?

Scott French

I think the six months is based upon what we think is an appropriate time to just reconfirm income eligibility in case there have been changes in income, given that it's really done on the back end.

Scott French

So it's not something that the individual in shelter needs to take action on.

Scott French

It's just it's a good checkpoint.

Scott French

So in case something has changed.

Scott French

We would then address it at that point.

Scott French

And if the person is no longer eligible, we wouldn't want to renew that letter.

Scott French

And we would want the shelter provider to also understand you need to engage this household around a different plan for housing stability and what might their pathway be.

Scott French

So that's what bases on the six month.

Scott French

It's really about just trying to confirm the income and those other baseline eligibilities have remained the same.

Crystal Hudson

How many people are deemed ineligible?

Crystal Hudson

after the six months based on that?

Scott French

I would need to get back to you on that data point.

Scott French

I'd need to talk to our data folks on that.

Crystal Hudson

Okay, just...

Erin Dalton

Yeah, I understand.

Erin Dalton

Sorry.

Erin Dalton

I understand where you're going.

Erin Dalton

Yeah, I understand what you're trying to get at.

Erin Dalton

I think the data you've already requested, which we do have, will tell you that time frame.

Erin Dalton

So from shopping letter to process to application submission, we'll give you that first data point.

Erin Dalton

I haven't looked at the data.

Erin Dalton

It's going to be longer than six months.

Erin Dalton

And so I understand the secondary question about, is that a meaningful?

Crystal Hudson

Yeah, I mean, I'm just I'm just thinking and I don't know the answer, to be clear, but I'm just thinking, you know, if somebody is eligible for a city FEPS voucher.

Crystal Hudson

Six months from that point, they're probably still eligible.

Crystal Hudson

They're more likely to be eligible than not, let's say, to still be eligible.

Crystal Hudson

And so I'm just trying to figure out why we have the six-month duration on that.

Crystal Hudson

And is that, and again, I don't know the answer, and I know that you may not know it in this moment, but something to consider is then, is that six-month...

Crystal Hudson

Duration or expiration necessary.

Crystal Hudson

And maybe there's another opportunity for streamlining the process that allows that shopping letter to be eligible a little bit longer.

Erin Dalton

Yeah, I don't know.

Erin Dalton

I understand.

Erin Dalton

And we've already testified that it is very rare that people are found ineligible.

Erin Dalton

It's only returns, really.

Erin Dalton

We've already testified to that.

Erin Dalton

So I understand.

Crystal Hudson

And then people have to go through the same hassle of, you know, all of that after the six months.

Crystal Hudson

But I'm glad you're with me on that one.