Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Banks asks total open work orders, Section 8 records, and physical needs

New York City Council · Sep 22, 2026 · starts 0:55:10 · 4 min 50 sec

Banks asks for total open work orders today in Section 9 and PAC and the cost to resolve them. Greene reports 606,583 Section 9 work orders, Beck reports 409 open PAC work orders in HUD pillar areas, and Greene says Section 8 has no work order records and cites the $78 billion physical needs assessment.

Chris Banks

And what are the total number of work orders open today in Section 9 and in PAC, respectively?

Daniel Greene

Thank you, Chair, for your question.

Daniel Greene

I'm going to first address the Section 9 side.

Daniel Greene

So as of September 21st, 2026,

Daniel Greene

NICHA had 606,583 open work orders broken down by maintenance, pro school trades, other crafts, and vendor work orders.

Daniel Greene

And so if I give you the breakdown, I'm just going to give you approximations just to speed it along.

Daniel Greene

Approximately 17,000 maintenance tickets were open as of, I guess it was as of yesterday.

Daniel Greene

310, about 311,000 skilled trade tickets.

Daniel Greene

58,000 work orders assigned to quote-unquote other crafts.

Daniel Greene

Vendor is 221,371 for that 606,500 total.

Chris Banks

And what is the total number of work orders, including NITRA-wide, including Section 9, Section 8, and PAC?

Chris Banks

And what would the estimated cost be to resolve this or the total?

Daniel Greene

Thank you, Chair, for your question.

Daniel Greene

I'm just going to allow Ms.

Daniel Greene

Beck to give the PAC numbers before we get into that next question.

Chris Banks

Yeah, yeah, go right ahead.

Heather Beck

Sure, thank you.

Heather Beck

Again, so we collect work order data on the HUD key pillar areas.

Heather Beck

So that includes work order information on elevators, heat, leaks, mold, and pests.

Heather Beck

So that is a subset of the work orders that are created at each of our properties.

Heather Beck

And we collect that information at the end of every month.

Heather Beck

So the information I have for you is as of August 31st.

Daniel Greene

Okay.

Heather Beck

It's very likely that some of the work orders that were opened on the 31st have been resolved and closed, but I just want to make sure that that is clear.

Heather Beck

So as of August 31st, there are 409 open work orders in the PAC portfolio among the 82,000 work orders that have been created over the past six years.

Heather Beck

So that's about one work order per 100 units.

Heather Beck

And again, because our PAC partners are responding and closing or resolving work orders, typically within one day, we would expect most of those 409 work orders to be closed at this point in September.

Daniel Greene

Okay.

Daniel Greene

And then the question that I posed just now.

Daniel Greene

So I want to note before I give this answer, on Section 8, NYCHA does not maintain records of open work orders within the Housing Choice Voucher Program.

Daniel Greene

Apartment conditions are monitored through the regular annual housing quality standards inspection.

Daniel Greene

And as such, we're not able to estimate the total cost to resolve those work orders for Section 8.

Daniel Greene

For Section 9...

Daniel Greene

I think the critical number here is our physical need assessment, which is the

Daniel Greene

which is the $78 billion, which will be reassessed in a couple of years.

Daniel Greene

That really is the number to address comprehensively all the root causes and all the physical conditions necessary to address it.

Daniel Greene

On average right now, we're seeing 2.5 million work orders created.

Daniel Greene

At NYCHA.

Daniel Greene

So to put that backlog in perspective, we have 600 on the Section 9 side, we have 606,000 work orders as of today.

Daniel Greene

But every year, we're seeing 2.5 million work orders created.

Daniel Greene

And we're addressing about just over 2.4 million of them with some with some, you know, small number of cancellations in there.

Daniel Greene

So that level of effort, which we're at, by the way, the highest level of closing repairs that we have been, you know, in any recent year,

Daniel Greene

really, we have to turn to our physical needs assessment because we need those comprehensive repairs in order to see that number really truly.

Chris Banks

What was the most recent needs assessment done?

Daniel Greene

The most recent one, I believe it was done in 2022, if I'm not mistaken.

Heather Beck

And published in 2023.

Daniel Greene

And published in 2023.

Daniel Greene

And that is the $78 billion.

Daniel Greene

And it will be refreshed in, I think, five years from then.

Daniel Greene

So 2027.

Daniel Greene

Seven.

Daniel Greene

Yep.

Heather Beck

That's true.

Daniel Greene

So, and that's handled by our asset and capital management.

Daniel Greene

So they would be able to give you that schedule in more detail on the property management guy.

Daniel Greene

But really, really.

Daniel Greene

The volume of work orders that we're experiencing right now is very high.

Daniel Greene

Because one thing I think it's important to note historically, before three, two years ago, we never inspected every apartment every year.

Daniel Greene

So now we're inspecting 100% of our apartments every year.

Daniel Greene

And when the maintenance worker goes in there, they're creating repair tickets because we're finding conditions that we probably have never found before.

Daniel Greene

We're proactively going into apartments, creating the work orders and prioritizing them.

Chris Banks

Okay.

Daniel Greene

Sorry.

Chris Banks

Thank you.