Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Cynthia Tibbs objects to PAC nondisclosure agreements and exclusion of elected officials

New York City Council · Sep 22, 2026 · starts 2:46:03 · 1 min 48 sec

Cynthia Tibbs says she is TA president of the West 97th Street Brownstones, part of a large PAC bundle on the Upper West Side. She says NYCHA real estate told resident leaders they must sign a nondisclosure agreement to participate in decision-making and that elected officials would be barred from future meetings.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

My name is Cynthia Tibbs.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

I'm the TA president of the Wissur Brownstones, 36 brownstones on the Upper West Side, which is currently being placed into the PAC program, along with 10 other developments.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

We are currently the biggest bundle that NYCHA has ever done.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

Last night, real estate came up here and told us leaders that unless we sign the nondisclosure agreement, we will not be a part of the decision making for our developments.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

This has never been done in the previous developments when it came to decision making, but they've decided to do it now.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

My elected officials accompanied the meeting with me, and they were also told that moving forward, they would not be permitted at any more meetings until after NYCHA decided who the developer would be for our meetings.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

This is unacceptable.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

This is not transparency.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

This is not democracy.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

And I understand how Eastchester Gardens may be the golden child for how PAC should run, but the majority of us don't get that privilege.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

We are treated like underclass citizens.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

We are not recognized.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

And I am having a meeting with my residents tonight because in no way do I plan on signing a nondisclosure where it's.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

says I can't talk to my residents without being in trouble.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

The one thing this three-page document has a lot of on it is the word terminate, terminate, terminate.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

That's unacceptable.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

They said this is what NITRA will be doing moving forward with all their PAC developments.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

This is not transparency.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

Shame on them.

Member of the Public - Cynthia Tibbs

Thank you for your time.