Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Schiffrin describes unanswered emails and Rowland's response on Signal content

New York City Council · Sep 22, 2026 · starts 2:15:07 · 1 min 15 sec

Schiffrin says she sent dozens of emails to City Hall and agencies since July without answers, unlike her experience with EU officials, and that after her paper came out Rowland texted her saying the Signal group information is the same as the regular press list, usually just links to press releases and livestreams.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

I sent dozens of emails to different parts of City Hall and to city agencies since July asking for information.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

When I did my PhD on disinformation, Google and Facebook didn't speak to me once in the years I was doing my research, but every single official

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

or government employee that I wrote to at the EU Commission or the EU Parliament met with me for at least an hour.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

So I'm very used to engaging with government officials as part of my academic research.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

And I was a little surprised when I didn't get an answer from anybody at all.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

So after the...

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

Paper came out, I did get a text message from Amelia Rowland and, you know, re-sent many of the questions I've been sending since July.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

So on Saturday, she sent me a text message about this particular question in which she said that the information in the signal group is not different at all from the information given to the regular press list.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

Quote, it is usually just a link to a press release and link to the announcement live stream on YouTube, Roland said in a text message on September 21st.

Member of the Public - Anya Schiffrin

But I'm looking forward to further clarification.