Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Gutiérrez raises equity in paid immersion programs

New York City Council · Sep 29, 2026 · starts 1:10:28 · 3 min 4 sec

Gutiérrez says many private immersion programs are unaffordable and often offer languages like French or Japanese. She asks how the city will ensure equitable access to multilingual early childhood education.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

And on that, this will be my last question related to this topic.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

I know that, for example, in my district, there are a number of schools that offer immersion as well in other languages.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

But in every instance, you know, parents are paying for this.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

And I know that there is an interest for many parents of all different sorts of income.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

They want to enroll their child.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

They just can't afford it.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

How are you all thinking about...

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Expansion and ensuring equitable access to multilingual education in early childhood for all families.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Because I feel like in some neighborhoods, this is where you'll see immersion programs that are usually not Spanish, right?

Jennifer Gutiérrez

It's like French or Japanese, you know?

Jennifer Gutiérrez

But how can we ensure equity?

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Because I think parents...

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Want to do that.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

And more than anything, they want to be able to ensure that their child is like learning another language, because like Gail said, we should we should already be doing that.

Erica Phillips

I think this is connected to just the focus on expanding child care options on, you know, addressing

Erica Phillips

of course, affordability broadly, but also making sure that we're providing programs that families want.

Erica Phillips

So we are intentional in working with community-based programs.

Erica Phillips

looking for opportunities where if we are able to expand, then we're able to work with more programs that might offer different types of dual language settings for young children.

Erica Phillips

But I will just say, we know that there is a lot of demand and interest for different types of multilingual programs.

Erica Phillips

And as you can hear from any of our responses, this is a priority for the chancellor, for the mayor, and making sure that we're working together across as many different options and making sure that principals and schools and superintendents,

Erica Phillips

if they hear of a need that we're working together to offer programs that the families are looking for.

Georgette Branch

And if I could just add, we also are very intentional with understanding that the purpose of bilingual education programs are, again, to support the multilingual learner.

Georgette Branch

And if we're thinking about expansion and what the community needs are, at the end of the day, it's what that community needs for the multilingual learner that lives in that community.

Georgette Branch

So if there's a significant population of students whose home language is Russian, then we're going to think about that when we're considering expansion.

Georgette Branch

While monolingual learners benefit from those programs, multilingual learners depend on those programs.

Georgette Branch

So that's definitely.

Georgette Branch

one of our driving markers around what we are looking for and when we're thinking about expansion.

Georgette Branch

I want to make that kind of like, you know.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

No, excellent.

Jennifer Gutiérrez

Thank you.