Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Menin asks public panel who should be third-party validators

New York City Council · Oct 5, 2026 · starts 6:51:29 · 1 min 35 sec

Menin opens questions to the public panel, asking who should be the independent, conflict-free, technologically capable third-party validator.

Carmen N. De La Rosa

Thank you so much.

Julie Menin

I really want to thank this panel.

Julie Menin

There's so much to unpack in what all of you said that I'll try to be brief.

Julie Menin

Jukay, I appreciated how you said that, first of all, we want to make sure that New York City remains the tech hub that it is, and that is how I began this hearing, by really talking about the 400,000 tech jobs that are here,

Julie Menin

by all the tech startups that are locating here, and that is something that we welcome and we want to encourage.

Julie Menin

I think that actually goes hand in hand with responsible regulation.

Julie Menin

The idea that these two ideas are mutually exclusive, I don't agree with at all.

Julie Menin

If we really want to instill trust and faith in AI, then the best thing we can do is responsible safeguards, which is what my colleagues and I are doing today with the bills we're putting forward.

Julie Menin

So thank you for saying that.

Julie Menin

It makes a lot of sense.

Julie Menin

I guess the question I have for any of you that want to answer it is,

Julie Menin

Yes, one of our bills requires this third-party validation, potentially a kill switch, a third-party validator who's free from conflicts of interest.

Julie Menin

I want to ask you the same question that I asked the companies earlier.

Julie Menin

Who then is best to be the third-party validator?

Julie Menin

Who is best positioned to be in that truly independent, free of conflict of interest, but...

Julie Menin

Up to speed technologically to provide that urgent validation.

Julie Menin

Okay, yeah, please.

Julie Menin

I'm opening it up to any of you.