Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Epstein asks panel to address electric-assist safety concerns

New York City Council · Oct 7, 2026 · starts 1:40:31 · 2 min 44 sec

Epstein notes recent e-bike safety hearings and resistance from DOT to allowing more electric assist. Winter says pedicabs need torque, not speed, average 6–10 mph in Central Park, and the industry has never had a pedicab-caused fatality; Camara says drivers need help, not speed.

Harvey D. Epstein

And I know Councilman Brewer has a question.

Harvey D. Epstein

There's one more, just around the electric assist issue, because we've heard concerns.

Harvey D. Epstein

We had a hearing, I think it was last week, I think it was, on e-bikes and e-bike safety and the proliferation of the problems in the city.

Harvey D. Epstein

And so there's real resistance.

Harvey D. Epstein

We've heard from DOT by allowing more.

Harvey D. Epstein

Bikes to have electric assist.

Harvey D. Epstein

How do we respond to those safety concerns if we allow electric assist in this industry?

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

To answer, Kenny is going to go ahead after you.

Member of the Public - Kenneth Winter

So really, for example, for us people that work in the park, for us it's really more of a torque thing, more an assistance.

Member of the Public - Kenneth Winter

There's not a real speed issue going on with pedicabs when it comes to Central Park, for example.

Member of the Public - Kenneth Winter

The only thing that I'm concerned about when it comes to people driving a pedicab with an electric scissor, again, most of the guys that are in the Midtown area, the Times Square area, you know, over by Empire State Building and so on, they do a lot of these donuts

Member of the Public - Kenneth Winter

on the thing.

Member of the Public - Kenneth Winter

Now, the industry has been around for 32 years.

Member of the Public - Kenneth Winter

We've never had a fatality caused by a pedicab.

Member of the Public - Kenneth Winter

We have a perfect safety record when it comes to this.

Member of the Public - Kenneth Winter

that the only time there's ever been a tragedy was caused by a reckless driver on 42nd Street, and that had nothing to do with the driver's operation of the vehicle.

Member of the Public - Kenneth Winter

I think that the 750 thing would be perfect because, I mean, really, it's really more about torque, not really about speed.

Member of the Public - Kenneth Winter

At least my maximum speed has been 14 miles an hour, and that's me trying really hard to do it.

Member of the Public - Kenneth Winter

Our average speed in Central Park, for example, is anywhere from 6 to 10 miles an hour.

Member of the Public - Kenneth Winter

And so because we're doing tours, you know.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

Yeah, and I just can't even say it.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

We're not looking for speed, you know.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

Again, we do a tour.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

People want to see things.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

And so our concern is not about 15, 20 miles per hour.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

If you can even go five miles per hour, that would be fine.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

Because people pay a lot of money to come to New York.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

They want to see things.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

And we have people here like 67 years old, 60 years old.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

They're not looking for speed.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

They just need help because if you have to pull three people.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

And again, you know, most major cities now in everywhere, Asia, Africa, Europe, they have electric assist except New York City, which is the best city in the world.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

And they still not allow us to use that.

Member of the Public - Makan Camara

And that's kind of something need to be changed.

Danielle Mendez

All of the bikes have it or nearly all the bikes already have it.

Danielle Mendez

And all that's happening is people like Kenny are having their bikes confiscated, having their lives impacted.

Danielle Mendez

But it doesn't actually change whether.

Danielle Mendez

The drivers are driving with pedal assist.