Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Joyce Bialik testifies on litter basket disparities and plastic bills

New York City Council · Oct 15, 2026 · starts 1:48:55 · 2 min 45 sec

Joyce Bialik, chair of the Manhattan Solid Waste Advisory Board's Plastic Task Force, supports oversight of waste equity and Intro 1041. She presents data showing East Harlem has fewer litter baskets and dirtier blocks than the Upper East Side and asks for hearings on plastic reduction bills.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

So I'm Joyce Bialik, chair of the Plastic Task Force for the Manhattan Solid Waste Advisory Board and a member of WIAC for Environmental Justice that has endorsed my testimony.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

I support your oversight of waste equity and environmental justice, 2585, as well as oversight in removal of litter baskets, Bill 1041.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

So Bill 1041.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

1041 will require the sanitation department to consult with the council and community boards before removing litter baskets.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

With fellow members of WE ACT, I studied disparities in the distribution of baskets based on a community's affluence.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

In 2023, with a larger population in East Harlem, 76K, than in the Upper East Side, 60K, East Harlem had 69 baskets to 2.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

60 in the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

In addition, only 17% of four street corner baskets were found in East Harlem compared to 95% in the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

In our Madison Avenue dirty block study, we found 51% dirty blocks in East Harlem, 6% in the Upper East Side.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

Less baskets, dirtier blocks, of course.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

These are environmental justice issues that can be eased with Bill 1041, which will require consultation with community boards before baskets are removed.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

Now just briefly about plastics.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

There are current council bills addressing plastic designed to reduce plastic in our midst.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

Plastic is an environmental justice issue.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

Plastic is produced from fossil fuels.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

Low-income people of color disproportionately reside near sites where there's drilling and refining for oil and gas, where

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

toxic chemicals are released, sites that are near polluted rivers and groundwater and near landfills and incinerators.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

So we seek a hearing for the following council plastic bills, 69, 300, 781, 795.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

They pertain to plastic beverage containers, artificial turf, and water fountains.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

Although these bills, they're not introduced.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

through this committee in order to adhere to 2585 regarding oversight of environmental justice.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

We are asking you to please reach out to your colleagues to hold hearings for them.

Member of the Public - Joyce Bialik

Thank you so much.