Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Hanif asks Masa Mehta about denial conversations and establishments

New York City Council · Oct 16, 2026 · starts 2:37:45 · 4 min 4 sec

Hanif asks what is said when Mehta is denied entry with her guide dog. Mehta says no documentation is required, describes a restaurant hostess asking her to leave because other customers might be uncomfortable, and says denials also happen at grocery stores, malls, movie theaters, and public agencies.

Shahana K. Hanif

question for Mossom.

Shahana K. Hanif

So thank you for sharing your testimony with us today and particularly about some of the experiences getting denied entry with your service dog.

Shahana K. Hanif

Could you share what

Shahana K. Hanif

What are, what's being said during those conversations?

Shahana K. Hanif

And when you're showing maybe your, that this dog who's accompanied you is a service animal, what's the exchange?

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

Yeah, absolutely.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

There's a couple different scenarios.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

Just to clarify, there is no documentation for service animals and a business cannot ask you legally for that documentation.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

I personally have an ID card that was issued from my guide dog school.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

But again, that is a courtesy that is not required.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

I usually show that just so they stop yelling at me.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

But again, that is not something that is required.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

Generally, I will, I'll get kind of a broad gambit.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

The last time in recent memory, I was denied.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

I went into a restaurant and I approached the counter to be seated and the hostess told me that

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

that I just needed to leave.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

And I was a little confused as to what factor I was being asked to leave about.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

But he specifically mentioned that he felt that the other customers at the restaurant would be uncomfortable with my service animal.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

So unfortunately, they would not be able to serve me.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

I was not able to

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

educate at the time in a way that he was able to, I guess, take in.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

I did ask for his manager.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

I'm suspicious that he didn't.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

Actually communicate to the manager because he did come back and tell me the chef himself said that I also needed to leave.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

So it was a bit awkward.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

I think that generally also one thing that we have to think about here is

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

It might not be a conversation of, oh, you have an emotional support animal.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

A lot of times the conversation is just no.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

And that's it.

Shahana K. Hanif

So what I'm hearing is a combination of restaurant management protocol with or without.

Shahana K. Hanif

Justified reason, just kind of like just saying no, but then also this element of the other patrons in our establishment are uncomfortable.

Shahana K. Hanif

So this combination of businesses not knowing that you don't have to provide documentation and that you are

Shahana K. Hanif

allowed to be in their establishment with your service dog and also others who are in the restaurant not knowing that you are indeed allowed to be in that restaurant with your service animal.

Shahana K. Hanif

So this like necessity of their needing to be broad public education

Shahana K. Hanif

detailing what the rules are around this is absolutely clear from what you have just shared.

Shahana K. Hanif

And so have there been establishments outside of restaurants that...

Shahana K. Hanif

You or others in your community have experienced denials?

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

Yes.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

Retail establishments.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

I have been denied from several small local grocery stores.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

I know that members of my community have been denied from shopping malls, movie theaters, public agencies.

Member of the Public - Masa Mehta

You name it across the board.