Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Q&A

Chair Williams and SIAP discuss applying civic cluster model in Southeast Queens

New York City Council · Oct 19, 2026 · starts 0:31:43 · 3 min 58 sec

Chair asks how the model would work in her district; Stern suggests funding points of strength to partner with more vulnerable areas, and Seifert urges a broad definition of nonprofit cultural providers and starting with a few places.

Nantasha M. Williams

Okay, I guess I'm struggling to visualize what that looks like.

Nantasha M. Williams

Are you saying like, for instance, I guess I'll use my district.

Nantasha M. Williams

Like I have, you know, there are some cultural institutions maybe that are the center for arts and culture in Southeast Queens.

Nantasha M. Williams

Are you saying like using...

Nantasha M. Williams

Localized hubs of individuals or organizations to then expand out within those communities.

Nantasha M. Williams

And then I guess in relation to us as council members, like how do we then use that model to support communities, especially communities that have been historically underserved?

Member of the Public - Mark Stern

Well, suppose there was a program that said identify points of strength across the city and fund them working in a partnership with other groups in more vulnerable parts of the district.

Member of the Public - Mark Stern

So I think that's sort of what we were imagining.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

I want to add, I noticed you used the word cultural institutions.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

So in other words, grantees, the people we know, the IRS, the 501c3, blah, blah, blah.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

When we say nonprofit, we mean not-for-profit.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

It doesn't mean if your parents'organ, a theater group showing at the rec center,

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

No revenue.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

You know, I mean, that's a not-for-profit at a public facility with a cultural center.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

The libraries, I know that's part of your committee.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

We also look at embedded programs, immigrant-serving social service organizations.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

So many of the immigrant and foreign-born organizations are cultural in our view.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

We take a very broad view.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

We don't just define things by the...

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

Official 501c3 nonprofit.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

Everything's nonprofit that isn't making money, okay?

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

And we try to capture that, and getting to that will take more work.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

It's five boroughs.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

You've got a gigantic city.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

Get it.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

Just pick a couple places to start.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

Don't go everywhere all at once.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

It's gigantic here, you know?

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

So pick a place where some of your council or some of your staff from DCL, it can be city planning.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

I happen to be biased toward planning.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

Already have a hook, you know, they're already there, but they will be cultural whether they're on your list or not.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

They're probably not CDF eligible, okay, or they may have gotten it together to apply and not made it.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

We're just saying that's what, because we're Philadelphians and we've been able to come back so much, we can do stuff like that.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

In another city, that's what we consider a five-city study with the five boroughs, right?

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

You know, it's a little different.

Member of the Public - Susan Seifert

So you have to...

Nantasha M. Williams

Yeah, no, I get it.

Nantasha M. Williams

you know, Councilmember Stevens and I have been on conversations with folks in Baltimore on a separate topic.

Nantasha M. Williams

And I think one of the things that we realize is it's not that we're not doing some of this, it's whether or not

Nantasha M. Williams

government is responding in the standardized institutional way, because, you know, I feel like in these localized communities, a lot of that like horizontal networking is happening.

Nantasha M. Williams

But what I find and what we found and

Nantasha M. Williams

if anyone else has any other questions, I'll open up to my colleagues, is that, you know, because New York City is such a big city, our government infrastructure is also not malleable.

Nantasha M. Williams

So it is not flexible to certain types of change, to how we allocate money to different groups, especially for specific city agencies.

Nantasha M. Williams

And that is an area of opportunity because I think that...

Nantasha M. Williams

We could better serve community, whether it be arts and culture or youth violence, is sort of the topic that we've been talking to the folks in Baltimore about.

Nantasha M. Williams

The way that their governments are able to adjust, like, it seems like almost impossible here.

Nantasha M. Williams

So, yeah, I do appreciate that.