Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

John Doyle presents petition for City Island ferry

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 3:18:47 · 2 min 43 sec

The City Island Rising petition has over 2,500 signatures; 43% of residents commute over an hour; EDC's 2018 study projected a 40% commute reduction; he asks the council to pass Intro 1032.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

Good afternoon, everybody.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

Thank you, Chair Maloney.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

Thank you, Councilmember Fedeas.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

And thank you to all the supporters of Intro 1032.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

Five years ago, after extensive discussions and at the suggestion of then-Senator Biagi, City on Rising started a Change.org petition to support ferry service to City Island.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

To even our surprise, the petition took off and now sits at over 2,500 signatures, more than double any other proposal.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

And I also have a few hundred in hand, which I will submit before the closing of the period here.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

This quickly snowballed into extensive outreach, op-eds, media coverage, debates, and discussions.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

We launched YesCityIslandFerry.com in 2023, pushing policymakers and advocacy groups like the Waterfront Alliance to work with us to make this happen.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

In 2024, community members met with then-Councilmember Marmorado and then-Economic Development Chair Committee Chair Amanda Fedeas to discuss bringing a ferry to City Island.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

In the last two years, we have lobbied and secured the support from elected officials, State Senator Natalia Fernandez, Assemblymember Benedetto, who you heard from earlier, and our current Councilmember, Councilmember Aldebar.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

So to anyone listening or watching at home, saying this bill came out of nowhere ignores the many hours community members have put into this campaign, the many documented efforts to get us to where we are today.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

In only two weeks, we were able to get 350 signatures to support new legislation, and as you can see, the overwhelming majority are from City Island.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

So first, I just want to say as a longtime City Island resident,

Member of the Public - John Doyle

35 years this August.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

I'm fortunate to work nearby.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

But the overwhelming amount of city islanders aren't so fortunate.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

In fact, according to the census, 43% of city islanders spent over an hour traveling for work, and that's only one way.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

We're talking about spending 10% of your day, or even more of your waking hours, commuting.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

According to the EDC's own 2018 study, residents would see their commute times drop by 40%.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

I encourage you to read the stories that have been submitted and to talk about how dramatically improving the lives of our neighbors.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

I think we should center them in the discussions.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

And I would just further just point out that there has been, you know, there have been 20 speaking storefronts.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

We have a video.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

We'll submit to the evidence.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

But this has been going on for over 20 years.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

It's time to try something new.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

Thank you, Chair.

Member of the Public - John Doyle

Thank you, Council Members.

Virginia Maloney

Thank you for your testimony.

Virginia Maloney

I want to thank Elizabeth Valdez for your holistic description of what accessibility on our near city ferry systems means.

Virginia Maloney

And thank you to the advocates for City Island.

Virginia Maloney

We've got our change.org petition here.

Virginia Maloney

More signatures than we can count.

Virginia Maloney

Any questions from the...

Virginia Maloney

And I'm excited to take the ferry to City Island someday.