Skip to content
Council Discourse

NYC Council meetings, chaptered and linked by time.

Independent project. Not affiliated with the New York City Council.

Created by Uzair Qadir

Inspired by Vikram Oberoi's City Meetings

Public Testimony

Kathy Sebeck says City Island Civic Association opposes ferry location

New York City Council · Oct 20, 2026 · starts 3:24:13 · 2 min 51 sec

Sebeck says the testimony portal shows more opposition than eight; a previous council member survey found residents did not want a ferry; she asks the bill to specify Orchard Beach and agrees with EDC's concerns.

Virginia Maloney

And next on Zoom, first Kathy Sebeck, followed by Dan McSweeney.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Good afternoon.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Can you hear me?

Virginia Maloney

Yes, we can hear you.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Oh, thank you so much.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

I was on the phone and the Zoom here.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

We submitted, my name is Kathy Seaback.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

I'm from the City Island Civic Association.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

We submitted our testimony along with many members of our community to the portal for a hearing and also to testify.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

At council.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

NYC, council.nyc.gov.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

I hope you look at all of that because I don't think Councilman Farias is eight opposed and 354 is an accurate portrayal.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

That may be the email she received, but the public is not asked to send the email to her.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

So I would hope you please consider the testimony in those two places.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

We also sent to her and to the over 1,700 signatures on petitions.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Our civic association has hundreds of members, and I hope you consider that before you move forward.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

The rollout of this bill, yes, ferry has been discussed quite a bit on City Hall for years.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Councilman Marmorato was not in support of a ferry here and did a survey and found the residents did not want it.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

And we requested Orchard Beach to be in the study.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Now, the parsing of words of it's adjacent, I think before they go forward with this bill, they should amend it to say Orchard Beach or is adjacent mean all of Palin Bay Park.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

I think it would be clear to the community and the public if we knew this, because it was very confusing to a lot of the residents.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Not that they didn't understand, but what does adjacent mean?

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

And I think a clear form of that would be fine.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

But you could read the testimony sitting on small.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

I appreciate Mr.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Wong because.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Almost everything Mr.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Wong said is part of our argument as some of the residents from City Island.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

I agree with what he said, and I'm glad a person that is an expert on this, that we are a pretty informed association.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

I don't think traffic will be relieved by a ferry.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Maybe when at Orchard Beach, the cars on the road would not come to Orchard Beach and take a ferry.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

But this has been an argument ongoing, and it was just rolled out on Friday by Councilman Abador.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Thank you.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

To let the community know.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

And also, Amanda Farias was an email to me on Sunday.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

That's not a lot of time.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

The community supports our effort.

Virginia Maloney

Thank you very much for your testimony.

Member of the Public - Kathy Sebeck

Thank you so much for listening.